San Diego Considers Ban on Flavored Tobacco Sales

Apr.25.2022
A proposed law in San Diego could end the sale of flavored tobacco products targeting youth, with controversy surrounding its potential impact.

According to a report by the TIMES of SAN DIEGO, the SAAFE Act proposed by San Diego City Council member Marni von Wilpert would ban the sale of flavored straws, flavored cigars, and minty cigarettes targeted at youth if passed. Hookah, premium flavored cigars, flavored loose tobacco, and non-flavored tobacco products would still be available for sale on store shelves.

 

With the proposal of the bill, an end to tobacco sales in San Diego is on the horizon, bringing relief to school districts, youth service organizations, healthcare workers, and parents.

 

The San Diego City Council will discuss the ordinance on Monday, April 25th. Experts predict that the meeting will be very lively.

 

The Neighborhood Market Association, a local tobacco industry lobbying group, has strongly opposed this regulation and cited a study from San Francisco, which found that removing flavored e-cigarettes from retail environments could lead to young people replacing them with traditional cigarettes.

 

Jonathan Winickoff, the Director of Pediatric Research at the esteemed Tobacco Research and Treatment Center at Massachusetts General Hospital, reviewed the study and disagreed with its findings. He pointed out that the study was conducted before the full implementation of the spice tobacco ban in San Francisco, and at the time of the research, only 17% of retailers were complying with the ban. Therefore, the analysis and results cited by opponents are invalid.

 

Winickoff and his colleagues cited data from Oakland that revealed a decrease in the use of regular cigarettes after the restriction of tobacco flavoring. More importantly, they highlighted research indicating that sales restrictions on tobacco flavors in San Francisco resulted in an overall reduction of almost 18% in tobacco use by young people aged 18-24.

 

Therefore, this study demonstrates that halting the sale of flavored tobacco is meaningful. The following facts should be taken into consideration:

 

Children are attracted to flavors. Young people are naturally attracted to sweet, fruity, and minty flavors. When addictive substances such as nicotine are hidden in flavors like passion fruit or sour apple, they are more likely to try them without hesitation.

 

Each vaping device of every flavor contains an amount of nicotine equivalent to one to ten packs of cigarettes. The nicotine content in each device is highly concentrated, and some teenagers consume an entire e-cigarette per day, effectively consuming the nicotine content of 20 to 200 cigarettes.

 

Teenagers' brains are more susceptible to addiction than adults' brains because they are still developing.

 

These facts emphasize why a survey showed that 4 out of every 10 high school students in the San Diego Unified School District have smoked.

 

Editor: Leung Ka-wai

 

Source: Times of San Diego

 

I apologize, but as an AI language model, I cannot provide a direct translation for that link as it is already written in journalistic English. The website, timesofsandiego.com, is a news publication that covers various stories and events happening in the San Diego area using standard journalistic language and style. Is there a specific article or content you need assistance with?

 

This document has been generated through artificial intelligence translation and is provided solely for the purposes of industry discourse and learning. Please note that the intellectual property rights of the content belong to the original media source or author. Owing to certain limitations in the translation process, there may be discrepancies between the translated text and the original content. We recommend referring to the original source for complete accuracy. In case of any inaccuracies, we invite you to reach out to us with corrections. If you believe any content has infringed upon your rights, please contact us immediately for its removal.

FCTC: Global tobacco control treaties to address nicotine addiction, tobacco’s impact on the environment and illicit tobacco trade
FCTC: Global tobacco control treaties to address nicotine addiction, tobacco’s impact on the environment and illicit tobacco trade
More than 1,400 delegates will gather in Geneva as two major global tobacco control treaties convene to address rising nicotine addiction, environmental harms, and illicit tobacco trade—key discussions that could shape the future of global tobacco control policy.
Nov.14
Philip Morris Korea Extends IQOS ILUMA i Warranty to 18 Months, Says Move Will Boost Smoke-Free Product Growth
Philip Morris Korea Extends IQOS ILUMA i Warranty to 18 Months, Says Move Will Boost Smoke-Free Product Growth
Philip Morris International’s Korea unit has extended the warranty for the “IQOS ILUMA i” heated tobacco series from 12 to 18 months, applying it retroactively to existing purchases, aiming to enhance user experience and market competitiveness.
Oct.15 by 2FIRSTS.ai
PMI’s Smoke-Free Playbook: What Jacek Olczak Really Told Wall Street
PMI’s Smoke-Free Playbook: What Jacek Olczak Really Told Wall Street
At the Morgan Stanley Global Consumer & Retail Conference on December 2, 2025, PMI CEO Jacek Olczak delivered a clear message: the company’s smoke-free shift is now its central strategy. From ZYN’s surge in the U.S. to IQOS’s global momentum and a changing regulatory tone, his remarks sounded less like an earnings update and more like a declaration of PMI’s smoke-free future.
PMI
Dec.03
PMI Compares Smoke-Free Policies in Three Countries: Japan and New Zealand Lead Tobacco Control, While Thailand’s Ban Stalls Harm Reduction
PMI Compares Smoke-Free Policies in Three Countries: Japan and New Zealand Lead Tobacco Control, While Thailand’s Ban Stalls Harm Reduction
PMI Malaysia says Japan and New Zealand’s regulated smoke-free alternatives have hastened smoking declines, whereas Thailand’s post-2014 ban drives smokers to cigarettes or the black market—evidence, PMI argues, that pairing regulated alternatives with traditional controls could improve public health faster.
Oct.15 by 2FIRSTS.ai
Smoking Among Korean Men in Their 30s Plummets as E-Cigarettes Become the Main Substitute
Smoking Among Korean Men in Their 30s Plummets as E-Cigarettes Become the Main Substitute
KDCA reports cigarette smoking among Korean men in their 30s fell from 48% (2015) to 28.5% (2024). Including e-cigarettes, overall use was 40.1% in 2024—just 4.9 points below 2019—suggesting a shift to alternatives.
Oct.09 by 2FIRSTS.ai
Illegal Market Surges After Kazakhstan Bans E-Cigarettes; Telegram Becomes the Main Trading Channel
Illegal Market Surges After Kazakhstan Bans E-Cigarettes; Telegram Becomes the Main Trading Channel
Since Kazakhstan banned e-cigarette sales in June 2024, transactions have gone underground, shifting to Telegram and some e-commerce platforms and making enforcement harder; related research indicates the ban has not significantly reduced demand.
Oct.20 by 2FIRSTS.ai