US Judge Rules Against FDA on Premium Cigar Regulation

Jul.07.2022
US Judge Rules Against FDA on Premium Cigar Regulation
A US judge ruled FDA's decision on regulating premium cigars as arbitrary and capricious, asks for briefing on decision reversal.

On Tuesday, a federal judge in the U.S. ruled that the FDA's decision to regulate premium cigars under the same federal laws as cigarettes and other tobacco products was arbitrary and capricious.


District Judge Amit Mehta in Washington D.C. has stated that the FDA disregarded relevant data on the health risks associated with high-quality cigars. He has requested the FDA and industry groups that question this regulation, including the Premium Cigar Association and the Cigar Rights of America, to submit briefs explaining why he should overturn the FDA's decision.


Michael Edney, the attorney for the plaintiff firm Steptoe & Johnson, stated that the family-owned manufacturer and retailer of high-quality cigars has long believed that the FDA has mishandled its regulation of premium cigars. He expressed gratitude for the court's ruling and the opportunity to pursue further legal action on this matter.


At this time, it is not possible to immediately reach out to the FDA for comment on this matter.


The focus of the lawsuit is the so-called certification rules passed by the agency in 2016, in which it exercised regulatory authority over a wide range of tobacco products, including premium cigars and cigarettes, under the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act.


The plaintiff stated that the organization considered and rejected high-quality cigars before finalizing its regulations, as well as during additional consultations in 2017 and 2018.


According to them, the FDA's regulations require cigar manufacturers to register their products annually and provide a list of ingredients for each product. They also require all products to undergo laboratory testing, which is impractical for "craftsmen" who produce high-quality handmade cigars.


Industry organizations state that unlike cigarettes and e-cigarettes, high-quality cigars are not appealing to young people and are not associated with addiction. They cite research indicating that young people are unlikely to use high-quality cigars, and those who do use them are unlikely to smoke cigars on a regular basis, thus not contributing to increased death rates.


On Monday, Mehta agreed that the FDA did not adequately consider the studies cited by the plaintiffs and instead claimed "there is no evidence to suggest" that high-quality cigars pose less of a health risk.


The judge wrote that when an institution unequivocally claims there is no evidence, while in fact there are relevant documented pieces of evidence, and the institution ignores or disregards it, it acts arbitrarily and capriciously.


The case is the lawsuit filed by the U.S. Cigar Association against the FDA in the District Court of Columbia, case number 16-cv-01460.


This article is a compilation of information from third-party sources and is intended solely for educational and informational purposes. All copyrights to the compiled information belong to the original media and authors, and any infringements should be reported for prompt removal.


This document has been generated through artificial intelligence translation and is provided solely for the purposes of industry discourse and learning. Please note that the intellectual property rights of the content belong to the original media source or author. Owing to certain limitations in the translation process, there may be discrepancies between the translated text and the original content. We recommend referring to the original source for complete accuracy. In case of any inaccuracies, we invite you to reach out to us with corrections. If you believe any content has infringed upon your rights, please contact us immediately for its removal.

Philippines DTI Reports $740K in Illegal E-Cigarette Seizures and Removal of 100 Million Violation Records This Year
Philippines DTI Reports $740K in Illegal E-Cigarette Seizures and Removal of 100 Million Violation Records This Year
Between January and May 2025, the Philippine DTI seized $740,000 worth of illegal e-cigarettes from 88 unauthorized brands. Over 104 million online violations were removed, 628 businesses flagged, 385 legal notices issued, and 10 brands suspended.
May.28
UK Disposable Vape Ban Spurs Stockpiling and Black Market Concerns
UK Disposable Vape Ban Spurs Stockpiling and Black Market Concerns
The UK is set to ban the sale of disposable vapes starting June 1, but surveys show that 82% of disposable vape users plan to stock up before the ban takes effect, while 34% say they would consider buying illicit disposable products.
May.19 by 2FIRSTS.ai
JTI Reports Strong Sales of Its Nicotine Pouches in the Philippines, Monthly Growth Reaches 23%
JTI Reports Strong Sales of Its Nicotine Pouches in the Philippines, Monthly Growth Reaches 23%
JTI sees strong growth potential for its smokeless nicotine product "Nordic Spirit" in the Philippines, with sales increasing monthly.
May.28 by 2FIRSTS.ai
VOZOL MAGIC 18000: Curved Box Design Disposable E-cigarette
VOZOL MAGIC 18000: Curved Box Design Disposable E-cigarette
VOZOL launches new disposable e-cigarette, MAGIC 18000, with curved box design and dual suction modes, targeting Middle East market.
Apr.21 by 2FIRSTS.ai
U.S. – Texas Amends Vaping Bill to Ban E-Cigarettes Containing Ingredients from China or “Hostile Nations”
U.S. – Texas Amends Vaping Bill to Ban E-Cigarettes Containing Ingredients from China or “Hostile Nations”
Texas has amended SB 2024 to ban e-cigarettes containing e-liquids from China or other “hostile nations,” upgrading violations to a Class A misdemeanor. The bill also expands oversight to nicotine-free products and strengthens restrictions on youth-targeted marketing.
Jun.04 by 2FIRSTS.ai
CAPHRA Calls on Malaysia to Adopt Risk-Proportionate Regulation to Avoid a Total Ban on E-Cigarettes
CAPHRA Calls on Malaysia to Adopt Risk-Proportionate Regulation to Avoid a Total Ban on E-Cigarettes
CAPHRA calls on Malaysia to adopt risk-proportionate regulation for e-cigarettes, criticizing WHO for ignoring harm reduction and warning that a ban could lead to a black market and increased health risks.
Apr.30 by 2FIRSTS.ai