InterTabac Live Report | Germany’s BfTG Warns: Over-Regulation Could Impact Europe’s Vaping Market

Sep.18.2025
At InterTabac, the German Alliance for Tobacco-Free Enjoyment (BfTG) warned that high taxation and over-regulation are undermining the vitality of the vaping market, and that potential flavor bans could further weaken the legal market in Europe.

Key Takeaways | BfTG Remarks at InterTabac

 

  • Rising taxes: Germany’s e-liquid tax will climb to €0.32/ml in 2024, above the EU average.

 

  • Flavor ban risks: In the Netherlands, bans shrank the legal market, boosted black sales, and increased youth access.

 

  • Illicit & cross-border trade: Illicit products already make up 40% of the German market; many consumers cross into France to buy cheaper products, hitting border businesses.

 

  • EU policy impacts: 2027 battery rules will end disposables; nicotine-based excise rates are seen as excessive; TPD revision unlikely before 2030.

 

  • Industry stance: Vaping must remain cheaper than smoking; over-regulation and flavor bans will only push consumers back to cigarettes or illicit markets.

 

2Firsts On-Site, Dortmund  — At the 2025 Dortmund NGP press conference, where 2Firsts was present for live coverage, Philip Drögemüller, Managing Director of the German Alliance for Tobacco-Free Enjoyment (Bündnis für Tabakfreien Genuss e.V.,BfTG), warned that excessive taxation and flavor restrictions could undermine the legal vaping market in Germany and across Europe, pushing consumers back to smoking or the illicit market.

 

Drögemüller noted that Germany has regulated e-cigarettes since 2016 and introduced an e-liquid tax in 2022. The current rate stands at €0.26 per milliliter and will rise to €0.32 in 2024 — significantly above the EU average of €0.20. “Regulation is important, but over-regulation risks destroying market potential,” he stressed.

 

InterTabac Live Report | Germany’s BfTG Warns: Over-Regulation Could Impact Europe’s Vaping Market
At the press conference, Philip Drögemüller (first on the left) is speaking

 

 

Flavor bans under scrutiny

 

 

A key concern is the growing debate over flavor bans. Drögemüller cited the Netherlands, where a flavor ban took effect in January 2024. Within three months, the regulated market collapsed, while black-market products surged, easily accessible even to young people. “It’s a failed experiment. Germany must not repeat this mistake,” he said.

 

 

Illicit trade on the rise

 

 

According to BfTG’s survey, illicit products already account for roughly 40% of the German vaping market, with industry members estimating a 30% loss in potential turnover. Drögemüller urged policymakers to strengthen enforcement capacity to curb the expanding black market.

 

InterTabac Live Report | Germany’s BfTG Warns: Over-Regulation Could Impact Europe’s Vaping Market
Philip Drögemüller |Photo Credit:Xing.com

 

 

Policy shifts and looming impacts

 

 

Drögemüller outlined several EU-level regulatory moves that could reshape the industry:

 

  •  Battery Regulation: Effective 2027, requiring removable batteries, effectively phasing out disposables in the EU.
  •  Excise Directive proposal: A tax model based on nicotine concentration — €0.12/ml below 15mg/ml, and €0.36/ml above. “This punishes smokers who rely on higher nicotine strengths to quit,” he warned.
  •  TPD revision: A new Tobacco Products Directive may not be implemented before 2030.

 

Border effects also add pressure: France has not introduced e-liquid taxation, encouraging cross-border purchases and causing losses for German companies near the frontier.

 

 

Clear stance

 

 

“Vaping products must remain cheaper than cigarettes to preserve harm-reduction benefits,” Drögemüller concluded. “Flavor bans and excessive taxes are not solutions — they only drive consumers back to smoking or unsafe illicit markets.”

 

2Firsts was on-site to capture key discussions and will continue to provide in-depth coverage of regulatory developments shaping Europe’s NGP industry.

 

For more on-the-ground coverage, visit the 2Firsts InterTabac Special Section。

 


InterTabac Live Report | Germany’s BfTG Warns: Over-Regulation Could Impact Europe’s Vaping Market

 

Japanese Addiction Psychiatrist Says Complete Abstinence Is Not Always the Goal of Harm Reduction | 2Firsts Interview
Japanese Addiction Psychiatrist Says Complete Abstinence Is Not Always the Goal of Harm Reduction | 2Firsts Interview
Complete abstinence is not always the goal of addiction treatment under a harm-reduction approach, Japanese psychiatrist Tomohiro Shirasaka told 2Firsts in Manila. In the interview, he discussed patients' quality of life, Japan's shift towards heated tobacco products, and the challenges of quitting smoking for people with mental illness. Drawing on addiction treatment work in the Philippines, he advocated support rather than punishment and questioned whether fear-based health warnings effectively address the reasons people continue smoking.
Nov.10
Los Angeles Cracks Down on Illicit Flavored Vapes and Counterfeit Goods: 12 Businesses Searched, 24 Arrested, Eight Truckloads Seized
Los Angeles Cracks Down on Illicit Flavored Vapes and Counterfeit Goods: 12 Businesses Searched, 24 Arrested, Eight Truckloads Seized
Los Angeles authorities searched 12 businesses and arrested 24 people during a multi-agency operation targeting illicit flavored vaping products, flavored cigarettes and counterfeit merchandise on October 22, 2026. The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department said approximately eight tractor-trailer loads of merchandise were seized. Alleged violations involved flavored tobacco sales restrictions, tobacco licensing requirements and counterfeit trademark laws. Local, state and federal agencies participated. Authorities have not disclosed the number, brands or value of vaping products seized. Investigations remain ongoing.
Enforcement
Oct.28
BAT Adds Former Apple General Counsel Bruce Sewell to Board as Finance, Legal, Marketing and Regional Leadership Shift
BAT Adds Former Apple General Counsel Bruce Sewell to Board as Finance, Legal, Marketing and Regional Leadership Shift
British American Tobacco has appointed former Apple Senior Vice President, General Counsel and Secretary Bruce Sewell as an independent non-executive director, effective January 1, 2027. He will also join BAT's Audit and Nominations Committees. BAT Chair Luc Jobin highlighted Sewell's experience in technology, government and regulatory affairs, public-company governance and AI-company boards. Over the past 18 months, BAT has changed or announced changes to its CFO, general counsel, CMO and APMEA regional leadership, while the main board has also seen multiple changes. The appointment comes as BAT advances Horizon 2030 and its Fit2Win transformation while expanding New Categories and reshaping parts of its digital, technology and operating structure.
Business
Oct.29
2Firsts Interview | Cigarette Sales Fall as Smokeless Alternatives Gain in U.S. Convenience Stores, NACS Says
2Firsts Interview | Cigarette Sales Fall as Smokeless Alternatives Gain in U.S. Convenience Stores, NACS Says
Ahead of the 2026 NACS Show, 2Firsts interviewed Chris Rapanick, NACS managing director of research, on changes reshaping the U.S. convenience-store tobacco and nicotine market. NACS data show cigarette sales declining while smokeless alternatives, including nicotine pouches, continue to grow. The interview also examines higher OTP margins, shifting backbar space, weaker store traffic, regulatory uncertainty and NACS’ outlook for 2027, offering a retailer-side view of one of the world’s largest nicotine markets.
Interview
Oct.03
Special Report | How Capital Is Reassessing the Global Tobacco and Modern Nicotine Industry: Lessons from a New York Forum
Special Report | How Capital Is Reassessing the Global Tobacco and Modern Nicotine Industry: Lessons from a New York Forum
Capital is reassessing the global tobacco and modern nicotine industry as heated tobacco, vaping and nicotine pouches reshape demand, profitability and regulation. At the 2026 New Approaches Summit in New York, investors and analysts examined whether smoke-free growth can sustain earnings, how regulation shapes startup value, and whether shareholder engagement can be more effective than divestment. The debate points to a broader shift: tobacco transition is increasingly becoming a capital-allocation, governance and valuation question.
Capital Markets
Oct.05
Special Report | From Oversupply to Supply Gaps: Global Tobacco Leaf Markets Diverge Ahead of 2027
Special Report | From Oversupply to Supply Gaps: Global Tobacco Leaf Markets Diverge Ahead of 2027
Global tobacco leaf markets diverged sharply in 2026, with India cutting authorised FCV production amid oversupply while Malawi faced a supply shortfall. U.S. demand improved in some leaf categories, but growers in Brazil, Colombia, Tanzania and Zimbabwe faced pressure from prices, buyer access, costs and weather. With nicotine consumption patterns also shifting, 2027 will test whether supply, demand and grower profitability can move back toward balance.
Oct.26