Alan Zhao: What the Rise of Nicotine Pouches Means for Tobacco Retailers

Mar.31
Alan Zhao: What the Rise of Nicotine Pouches Means for Tobacco Retailers
Alan Zhao argues that nicotine pouches are no longer a niche alternative, but a force quietly reshaping the future of tobacco retail. For distributors and retailers, the real risk is not missing a trend—it is moving too late, after regulation tightens, shelf space hardens and the market begins to choose its winners.

● This article was commissioned by Retailers for the Future, a Spanish trade magazine serving the tobacco retail channel, and was published in V.2 [2026] of the magazine. The text presented here is the original English manuscript.

● This article reflects the author’s personal views only.

 

Alan Zhao: What the Rise of Nicotine Pouches Means for Tobacco Retailers

Alan Zhao’s commissioned opinion piece for the Spanish tobacco retail magazine Retailers for the Future has been published in V.2 [2026] of the journal.

 

The Role of Nicotine Pouches in the Global Tobacco Alternatives Market

The role of nicotine pouches is no longer peripheral.

 

By Alan Zhao

February 2026

 

In early February, PMI and BAT released their 2025 annual results. PMI’s nicotine pouch shipments rose 36 percent, driven by ZYN in the United States, while BAT’s Modern Oral volumes increased more than 47 percent, led by Velo. This is not incremental growth. It reflects a structural reallocation of industry focus.

 

For over a century, combustion defines tobacco. Over the past two decades, heated products remove fire, e-cigarettes remove the leaf, and nicotine pouches remove smoke—shifting consumption from inhalation to oral absorption and separating nicotine from combustible tobacco.

 

Nicotine pouches expand the geography of use. Without smoke or vapor, consumption becomes discreet and less dependent on space. Workplaces, hospitality venues, and regulated indoor environments that restrict inhaled products represent a fundamentally different context for oral nicotine.

 

Though often framed within harm reduction debates, the category’s immediate relevance for the trade lies in behavioral change—and in the industrial logic that follows. Unlike electronic cigarettes, which depend on device ecosystems and hardware differentiation, nicotine pouches are structurally simpler. They are standardized oral products rather than hardware platforms. In mature markets, retailers will not need dozens of pouch brands. A focused portfolio of three to five strong players can meet most demand. Shelf space is finite; profitability depends on efficiency.

 

Regulation is redefining the terrain. Child-resistant packaging, nicotine strength calibration to prevent unintended overconsumption, and long-term research into oral and gum health are central policy debates. Even within the European Union, divergence is clear. Spain has proposed strict strength and flavor limits, while Nordic countries, drawing on decades of experience with oral nicotine products, take a different view.

 

Regulatory uncertainty introduces volatility. Volatility introduces risk. In transitional markets, risk becomes a sorting mechanism. Those with long-term conviction, operational discipline, and strategic courage gain ground while others hesitate.

 

For brands, the direction is unmistakable. No serious tobacco company can remain confined to combustible products. Nicotine pouches offer one of the fastest and most accessible entry points into next-generation nicotine markets.

 

For distributors, the cycle is clear. In 2025, nicotine pouch brands surge. In 2026, that momentum begins to move downstream. Brand proliferation becomes channel leverage—bringing stronger negotiating power, promotional support, and margin gains for those prepared to manage it.

 

For retailers, engagement does not require radical reinvention. Pouches demand neither complex device displays nor technical servicing. Beginning with a disciplined range allows rapid learning, consumer dialogue, and early authority in a category still defining its structure.

 

Consolidation will follow expansion. Regulatory frameworks will harden. Shelf space will consolidate. The advantage lies not in waiting for clarity, but in positioning before clarity arrives.

 

In a market defined by transition, the greatest risk is not miscalculation—but inertia.


Further reading

 

2Firsts Perspectives
2Firsts Perspectives
2Firsts Perspectives
www.2firsts.com

BAT’s Product Strategy Reset: A Structural Analysis of Its Post-FY2025 Competitive Architecture
BAT’s Product Strategy Reset: A Structural Analysis of Its Post-FY2025 Competitive Architecture
Drawing on BAT’s FY2025 results and earnings call, 2Firsts finds the company shifting from category expansion to competitive entrenchment across Vapour, Modern Oral, Heated Products and Combustibles. The strategy centers on connected devices, geographic customization and portfolio tiering. While structurally coherent, financial returns depend on consistent regulatory enforcement against illicit competitors, making policy execution a key variable for 2026 performance.
Feb.12
Belgium Calls for EU-Wide Limits on Vape Ingredients and Ban on Disposable E-Cigarettes
Belgium Calls for EU-Wide Limits on Vape Ingredients and Ban on Disposable E-Cigarettes
Belgian Health Minister Frank Vandenbroucke has called on the European Union to take stronger action on vaping, saying it is becoming an “epidemic” and accusing the industry of targeting young people.
Mar.26 by 2FIRSTS.ai
Spain’s Nicotine Pouch Sales Reached 5 Million Cans in 2025, Industry Says 2026 Could Hit 8 Million
Spain’s Nicotine Pouch Sales Reached 5 Million Cans in 2025, Industry Says 2026 Could Hit 8 Million
Spain’s Nicotine Pouch Association said nicotine pouch sales in Spain reached 5 million cans of 20 units in 2025 and are expected to rise 60% to 8 million in 2026. The group said there are currently 20 to 30 brands on the Spanish market and called for regulation proportionate to product risk. It also opposed a proposal to reduce nicotine content to 0.99 mg per pouch, saying it would amount to a de facto ban on the category.
Mar.19 by 2FIRSTS.ai
JTI UK Updates Nordic Spirit Packaging to Strengthen “Strength and Flavour” Guidance
JTI UK Updates Nordic Spirit Packaging to Strengthen “Strength and Flavour” Guidance
Japan Tobacco International UK (JTI UK) has unveiled a refreshed brand identity for Nordic Spirit nicotine pouches. The new packaging is now live on JTI360 and will roll out to shelves over the coming months. The updated design strengthens on-pack guidance on strength and flavour, adding slower/faster release cues and a six-dot strength system (6–17mg). Each can contains 20 pouches and includes a lid compartment for storing used pouches before disposal.
Mar.04 by 2FIRSTS.ai
Nicotine Becomes Second-Largest Revenue Source for Couche-Tard in Fiscal 2025
Nicotine Becomes Second-Largest Revenue Source for Couche-Tard in Fiscal 2025
Alimentation Couche-Tard reported that nicotine products accounted for 9% of total revenue in fiscal 2025, making it the company’s second-largest revenue source after fuel, according to its latest Business Strategy Update.
Market
Feb.19
BAT CEO Says 2026 Return to Growth Hinges on U.S. Enforcement, Highlights Oral Leadership
BAT CEO Says 2026 Return to Growth Hinges on U.S. Enforcement, Highlights Oral Leadership
British American Tobacco said 2026 will mark a return to its mid-term growth algorithm, but CEO Tadeu Marroco stressed that deliverywill depend heavily on enforcement against illicit vapour products in the United States. Speaking at the FY2025 results call, he positioned Modern Oral as the company’s primary structural growth engine, reframed accelerating cigarette declines through “poly-usage,” and reinforced capital discipline with an expanded share buyback plan.
Feb.12