Exploring the Potential of THR Integration in Harm Reduction

Nov.23.2022
Exploring the Potential of THR Integration in Harm Reduction
The 13th National Injury Reduction Conference held in Puerto Rico addressed harm reduction topics such as drug use, tobacco use, and racial justice.

Image source: Filter. The following article is written by Kevin Garcia, a harm reduction researcher at Filter.


The 13th National Injury Reduction Conference took place in mid-October in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Approximately 2,800 injury reduction experts from the United States and other countries attended the conference, which focused on topics such as preventing opioid abuse, drug testing, racial justice, and sex work.


I also joined a group focused on harm reduction in tobacco. Given the occasional differences between tobacco harm reduction and other forms of harm reduction work, it is crucial to have ongoing dialogue on how to keep them aligned. Including this issue in the group's discussions is significant.


Therefore, I took this opportunity to ask some of the attendees about their thoughts. Their answers reflected some obstacles to better understanding, their personal experiences with THR, and some truly encouraging interest in incorporating THR into their work.


Electronic cigarettes? Those things are too scary for you.


Unfortunately, after non-profit organizations and public health agencies in the United States launched a relentless campaign of misinformation about the use of e-cigarettes, some misunderstandings have persisted – even among those who are trying to reduce harm. "E-cigarettes? Those things are just too scary for you," said one anonymous participant who was smoking. Evidence shows that while using e-cigarettes is not completely risk-free, it is much less harmful than traditional cigarettes. For example, the Royal College of Physicians in the UK notes that the long-term harm from e-cigarettes is unlikely to exceed 5% of the harm caused by smoking. Other harm-reducing alternatives, such as oral snus and "heat not burn" tobacco products, are also available. Nathan Smiddy, a harm reduction educator with A New Path in California, is uncertain about some health issues despite using e-cigarettes himself. "I don't know if popcorn lung is a real thing. I've never researched it. To me, using e-cigarettes costs less than smoking and feels better." Smiddy's primary motivation for switching was economic, which is an inspiring fact for debates about e-cigarette and cigarette taxes. "To be honest, cigarettes are very expensive. I don't think I can afford them now. So I bought an e-cigarette and stuck with it. I started smoking/using e-cigarettes at 15 and I'm 30 now. I feel it's safer, but I have no evidence to prove it. My overall health and quality of life have simply improved from the switch. And I don't wake up coughing up phlegm." Harm reducers often speak candidly about their lack of knowledge about THR, which is a good starting point for discussion.


I have many customers who have switched to using e-cigarettes instead of smoking traditional cigarettes.


I don't fully understand its scientific validity, but I will speak candidly," said Gillian Garton, who serves as a medical case manager for the Red Project in Grand Rapids, Michigan, and emphasized that she is speaking only on her own behalf. "I do know that some people use vaping to reduce their cigarette consumption, or switch entirely to vaping because I know there have been some changes in health. I have many clients who have switched to vaping instead of smoking cigarettes.


In fact, she did the same. "I used to smoke a lot before, starting at around 15 years old. I have been trying to quit smoking for a long time, so I switched to using e-cigarettes mainly for my own health.


Garton acknowledges the recent trend of banning electronic cigarettes and the potential harmful consequences that may arise. "I am aware that there have been many legislative attempts to ban electronic cigarettes," she said. She pointed out that people's reaction may be: "I do not have the opportunity to use this type of electronic cigarette, so perhaps I have to buy tobacco, but I still crave an electronic cigarette.


When it comes to the ban, I didn't see a positive side, only a negative side," said Presto Crespo, a resident of the Bronx. "People will just go back to smoking. Or they'll make their own stuff; sometimes it might be safe, sometimes it might be harmful to the body.


During our group discussion, we debunked myths and discussed the necessity of integrating THR in a wider field. Following this, some attendees stated that they are now giving more consideration to these matters.


I hadn't given much thought to the issue before our group discussion," said Crespo. "I believe I may have succumbed to some misinformation about e-cigarettes, but as a general skeptic, I always thought that something seemed off and couldn't be entirely true. However, I do agree that it's the way big tobacco companies are getting the new generation addicted to their products," they continued. However, their perspective was challenged after seeing their roommate transition from smoking to using e-cigarettes. "It was helpful to see that he felt like he had better lung capacity and was no longer constantly coughing and spitting.


Despite this, when it comes to evidence, "I don't know if there is a reduction in harm when transitioning from cigarettes to e-cigarettes," Crespo said. "E-cigarettes are everywhere. But some people still believe that e-cigarettes can explode.


I know someone who cannot take any other medication because they are taking methadone, so cigarettes are their only option. When I suggested trying e-cigarettes to this person, they refused, fearing that they would explode in their face. This person is clearly misinformed and continues to consume these packaged cigarettes.


After this conversation, I gained a better understanding of why this falls completely under the category of reducing harm.


I do not regularly use drugs or smoke," said Dan Coello, the project director of NEXT Distro, a company that provides harm reduction supplies such as naloxone and syringes through online purchases and mail delivery. "Before attending the group discussion, my knowledge of harm reduction was almost nonexistent...I believed that many of the risks we dealt with in the harm reduction movement were simply a matter of overuse or overconsumption. After the lecture, I came to understand that this falls completely within the realm of harm reduction.


What are the prospects of including tobacco harm reduction (THR) as a means of minimizing the harm caused by drug addiction for those who are prohibited from using drugs? After all, in the US alone, smoking is responsible for almost 500,000 deaths each year – more than any other substance – and a high proportion of illegal drug users also smoke.


Yes, people haven't really noticed this, what I mean is that humans tend to focus very strictly on immediate benefits and risks, and we're not very good at long-term thinking. Therefore, I believe that theoretical ideas like, for example, a large number of people dying from lung cancer in the future, don't feel as immediate as the direct risk of overdosing on medication.


Garton agrees with this viewpoint: "What I want to say is that tobacco is not a top priority in the harm reduction movement. Additionally, the shame associated with smoking tobacco is not as great as the shame associated with using other substances. Focusing attention on issues with higher levels of stigma is out of touch. This is not to say that I believe harm reduction advocates do not care about THR, but rather that we have a bigger stigmatization problem when it comes to other substances.


I believe that THR needs to be taken more seriously within the human resources community," said Crespo. "We are very concerned about cases of overwork, where people become ill quickly. We are working hard to prevent these situations, but we also need to focus on the long-term well-being of our employees. I don't think this is being discussed enough.


Communicating with tobacco users is currently something we can pursue.


I don't think the actions being called for within the community have been fully realized yet, such as understanding what exactly we can do," Coello said. "One thing we can start with is connecting two different worlds, such as those who are passionate about reducing tobacco harm and those who advocate for harm reduction in general. Therefore, first and foremost, there needs to be solid communication and friendship. Then, although the legal status of drugs may differ, the overall values of harm reduction should be consistent. Everyone needs to have a shared understanding of what it is and what can be done to reduce harm.


We already know and understand how to communicate with people who use electronic cigarettes, and we can draw on that experience to communicate with people who use tobacco," he continued. "I am confident that many of our participants smoke or use e-cigarettes; we can leverage our ability to reach these individuals and offer safer alternatives to smoking or combustion-based tobacco use or methods of nicotine delivery.


Personally, I want to learn more and better understand THR, as well as how NEXT can specifically initiate such things," summarized Coello. "I am not sure if we have reached a stage where meaningful changes can be made, but I hope that NEXT can play a role in the future.


Statement:


The content of this article is compiled from third-party information and is intended for industry communication and learning purposes.


This article does not reflect the views of 2FIRSTS, and 2FIRSTS cannot confirm the truthfulness or accuracy of its content. The translation of this article is intended solely for industry exchange and research.


Due to limitations in the quality of the translation process, the translated article may not fully reflect the original text. Please refer to the original article for accuracy.


In regards to any domestic, Hong Kong, Macau, Taiwan, or foreign-related statements and positions, 2FIRSTS is fully aligned with the Chinese government.


The copyright of compiled information belongs to the original media and author. If there is any infringement, please contact us for deletion.



Disclaimer

This article is provided solely for professional research, industry discussion, and informational purposes. Any references to brands, companies, products, technologies, or policies are made for factual reporting and analytical purposes only, and do not constitute endorsement, recommendation, promotion, or advertising by 2Firsts.

Nicotine-containing products, including but not limited to cigarettes, e-cigarettes, heated tobacco products, and nicotine pouches, carry significant health risks. Readers are responsible for complying with all applicable laws and regulations in their respective jurisdictions, including age restrictions and access limitations.

The information contained in this article should not be regarded as investment, legal, medical, regulatory, or commercial advice. While 2Firsts strives to ensure the accuracy and reliability of its content, it does not assume liability for any direct or indirect loss arising from errors, omissions, inaccuracies, or reliance on the information contained herein.

This article is not intended for individuals below the legal age for accessing tobacco or nicotine-related information in their jurisdiction.

 

Copyright Notice

This article is either original content produced by 2Firsts or content reproduced, translated, summarized, or adapted from third-party sources with attribution where applicable. The intellectual property rights of the original content remain with 2Firsts or the respective original rights holders.

No individual or organization may copy, reproduce, distribute, republish, modify, translate, or otherwise use this content without prior authorization. Any unauthorized use may result in legal action.

For copyright-related inquiries, corrections, or removal requests, please contact: info@2firsts.com.

 

AI-Assisted Translation and Editing Notice

Portions of this article may have been translated, edited, or reviewed with the assistance of artificial intelligence tools to improve efficiency and readability. Due to the limitations of AI-assisted translation and editing, discrepancies, omissions, or inaccuracies may exist when compared with the original source.

Where applicable, readers are advised to refer to the original source for the most complete and accurate information. If you identify any errors or believe that any content infringes upon your rights, please contact us at info@2firsts.com, and we will review and address the matter promptly.

Product | Philip Morris Korea Launches Two TEREA ONYX Capsule Tobacco Sticks, Expanding Portfolio to Five Lines
Product | Philip Morris Korea Launches Two TEREA ONYX Capsule Tobacco Sticks, Expanding Portfolio to Five Lines
Philip Morris Korea launched TEREA ONYX, a new tobacco stick line for IQOS ILUMA devices, on October 15, 2026. The initial products, AMANG PEARL and CALI PEARL, feature tropical-inspired flavors, Fresh Filters and capsules designed to deliver different flavor experiences before and after activation. Both are priced at KRW 4,800 per pack and are available at convenience stores nationwide and IQOS-operated stores in South Korea. The launch expands the Korean TEREA portfolio from four product lines to five, following earlier capsule tobacco stick additions in 2026.
product
Oct.23
Product | Japan Tobacco Expands Nordic Spirit Nicotine Pouch Range to Eight SKUs in Japan, Launches Melon Variant and Broadens Mint Retail Distribution
Product | Japan Tobacco Expands Nordic Spirit Nicotine Pouch Range to Eight SKUs in Japan, Launches Melon Variant and Broadens Mint Retail Distribution
Japan Tobacco Inc. (JT) launched Nordic Spirit Rich Melon Medium through selected tobacco retailers in Japan on November 2, 2026, while expanding physical retail distribution for three existing mint products previously sold through the CLUB JT online store. The melon launch brings Nordic Spirit's Japanese portfolio to eight SKUs. All four products are manufactured in Sweden, contain a standard 14 pouches per can and retail for ¥500 including tax. Since introducing Nordic Spirit in Japan in March, JT has expanded the brand's product lineup and distribution through its online store, convenience stores and selected tobacco retailers.
product
Nov.04
Indonesia's Influential Islamic Body MUI Urges Vape Permit Freeze, Raising Uncertainty for 200 Manufacturers
Indonesia's Influential Islamic Body MUI Urges Vape Permit Freeze, Raising Uncertainty for 200 Manufacturers
Indonesia's Ulema Council (MUI) published Fatwa No. 131/2026 on November 9, declaring electronic cigarette use, production and trade haram under Islamic religious rules. The council urged the Industry Ministry to prohibit the issuance of vape industry permits and review licensing policies, while calling on the president and parliament to enact a comprehensive ban. On November 10, the Constitutional Court heard a challenge to provisions of the 2023 Health Law seeking a prohibition on vape production, importation, distribution and use. The Health Ministry said on November 11 it was studying stronger restrictions, including a possible ban on circulation, while industry association APVI called for tighter oversight rather than a total ban. Indonesia's Industry Ministry previously estimated the sector comprises about 200 companies, Rp31 trillion ($1.7 billion) in cumulative investment and approximately 100,000 supply-chain jobs. No nationwide statutory ban has been enacted.
Regulations
Nov.12
Product | KIWI Launches Spark 2 and Spark 2 Pro in Germany, Two Hardware Tiers Share Backward-Compatible 2ml Pods
Product | KIWI Launches Spark 2 and Spark 2 Pro in Germany, Two Hardware Tiers Share Backward-Compatible 2ml Pods
KIWI has launched the Spark 2 and Spark 2 Pro refillable pod systems in Germany at official prices of €18 and €29, respectively. Spark 2 uses an 800mAh removable lithium-ion battery in a pen-style body, while Spark 2 Pro features a 1,400mAh removable battery, a box-shaped design and vibration feedback every 20 puffs. Both devices use the same 2ml Spark V2 pods in 0.8Ω and 1.2Ω versions, with AirSync airflow adjustment and a choice between Cotton Tips and conventional Drip Tips. The new pods also remain compatible with the original KIWI Spark.
News
Sep.29 by 2Firsts Perspectives
Pennsylvania Vape Directory Enforcement Starts Oct. 19, Barring Retail Sales of Unlisted Products
Pennsylvania Vape Directory Enforcement Starts Oct. 19, Barring Retail Sales of Unlisted Products
Pennsylvania's Act 57 vape directory regime will reach the end of its 120-day inventory transition period on Oct. 19. Nicotine-containing e-cigarettes intended for retail sale in the state that are not listed on the Attorney General's ENDS directory will then be barred from retail sale and treated as contraband subject to seizure, forfeiture and destruction. Manufacturers face annual product certification, brand- and style-based fees and a minimum $50,000 surety bond, while retailers and wholesalers must source through licensed channels and monitor the directory.
Regulations
Oct.08
North Carolina Tightens Vape Product Directory Enforcement, Expands State and Local Powers as Violators Face Fines, Product Seizures and License Suspension or Revocation
North Carolina Tightens Vape Product Directory Enforcement, Expands State and Local Powers as Violators Face Fines, Product Seizures and License Suspension or Revocation
North Carolina has expanded enforcement of its vapor product directory rules, authorizing more state and local law enforcement participation and establishing a task force led by the State Bureau of Investigation. The legislation requires at least one unannounced compliance inspection annually for retailers, distributors and wholesalers handling covered products. Penalties effective October 1, 2026, include civil fines of $500–$750 for a first violation and $1,000–$1,500 for repeated violations within 12 months, along with potential license suspension or revocation. Manufacturers may face penalties of $10,000 per unlisted product. The measures strengthen the product directory system established in 2024.
Regulations
Oct.28