Irish Court Approves Challenge to EU Tobacco Directive

Jan.13.2023
Irish Court Approves Challenge to EU Tobacco Directive
Irish high court permits tobacco companies to challenge EU directive on flavored tobacco in e-cigarettes.

The Irish High Court has allowed two tobacco companies to challenge a new EU directive that prohibits the use of flavored heated tobacco products in electronic cigarettes.


The state is set to adopt new EU laws by July next year. However, the country's oldest tobacco manufacturer, PJ Carroll and Co Ltd, and UK marketing and sales company, Nicoventures Trading Ltd, are claiming that the EU directive is invalid. They are challenging Ireland's Minister of Health and Minister of Justice.


Under previous regulations, flavoring tobacco products during heating was not prohibited, but the European Commission has made changes to this and is hoping that member states will implement the ban before July 23.


These products require smokers to consume half the amount of tobacco compared to traditional cigarettes. They are electronic devices powered by batteries and are used to inhale heated tobacco instead of burning it. This process produces an aerosol containing nicotine, which the user then inhales.


They come in various flavors such as bubble gum, chocolate, and marshmallow. Critics argue that these flavors attract young users, while proponents believe they can help those trying to quit smoking.


In 2021, PJ Carroll, which holds a 10% market share in the Irish electronic cigarette market, announced that it is taking steps to commercialize heated tobacco products in the country, including flavored products.


However, the company stated that the EU ban on these products severely impairs its ability to "fully leverage unique opportunities and become the first company to launch heated tobacco products for adult smokers in the Irish market, otherwise they will continue to smoke.


Simon Carroll, director and trade manager of PJ Carroll, has stated in a sworn affidavit that the ban will also harm significant investments by British American Tobacco (BAT) group, which owns Irish and British companies, in developing "products". Such products would reduce health risks compared to traditional cigarettes while still meeting the preferences of Irish adult smokers, he said, adding that otherwise they will continue to smoke.


He stated that the restriction also has significant effects on the implementation of public health policies and anti-smoking campaigns, as traditional cigarettes have acceptable alternatives.


Tobacco companies PJ Carroll and Nicoventures have written a letter to the Minister for Health and the Attorney General, but have been informed that it is too early to challenge in any Irish court as many applicants, including PJ Carroll and Nicoventures, have already initiated a direct European Union challenge in the European Court of Justice (CJEU).


PJ Carroll and Nicoventures submitted an application to challenge the upcoming implementation of a directive in Ireland, which was confirmed by the Health Minister to take effect in July next year. The application was submitted to Judge Charles Meenan on Wednesday. As the application was unilaterally filed, only the plaintiff's representative appeared in court. The purpose of the application is to challenge the directive's intention to be converted into Irish law.


PJ Carroll and Margaret Gray SC of Nicoventures argue that their case is based on the accusation that the European Commission illegally extended the directive to cover their clients' products, without providing proper reasoning.


These companies claim that, among other things, the new directive is invalid because it constitutes an illegal exercise of power under the previous Tobacco Products Directive (TPD).


They also stated that the committee's assessment of "significant changes in circumstances" (when introducing a new ban) goes beyond the scope of the TPD's authority.


The court also learned that these companies will request to bring this matter before the European Union court for an initial ruling.


The judge expressed satisfaction with the approval but stated that he believed the mention of the CJEU must be dealt with first before addressing any other matter. He said that the case may return next month.



Disclaimer

This article is provided solely for professional research, industry discussion, and informational purposes. Any references to brands, companies, products, technologies, or policies are made for factual reporting and analytical purposes only, and do not constitute endorsement, recommendation, promotion, or advertising by 2Firsts.

Nicotine-containing products, including but not limited to cigarettes, e-cigarettes, heated tobacco products, and nicotine pouches, carry significant health risks. Readers are responsible for complying with all applicable laws and regulations in their respective jurisdictions, including age restrictions and access limitations.

The information contained in this article should not be regarded as investment, legal, medical, regulatory, or commercial advice. While 2Firsts strives to ensure the accuracy and reliability of its content, it does not assume liability for any direct or indirect loss arising from errors, omissions, inaccuracies, or reliance on the information contained herein.

This article is not intended for individuals below the legal age for accessing tobacco or nicotine-related information in their jurisdiction.

 

Copyright Notice

This article is either original content produced by 2Firsts or content reproduced, translated, summarized, or adapted from third-party sources with attribution where applicable. The intellectual property rights of the original content remain with 2Firsts or the respective original rights holders.

No individual or organization may copy, reproduce, distribute, republish, modify, translate, or otherwise use this content without prior authorization. Any unauthorized use may result in legal action.

For copyright-related inquiries, corrections, or removal requests, please contact: info@2firsts.com.

 

AI-Assisted Translation and Editing Notice

Portions of this article may have been translated, edited, or reviewed with the assistance of artificial intelligence tools to improve efficiency and readability. Due to the limitations of AI-assisted translation and editing, discrepancies, omissions, or inaccuracies may exist when compared with the original source.

Where applicable, readers are advised to refer to the original source for the most complete and accurate information. If you identify any errors or believe that any content infringes upon your rights, please contact us at info@2firsts.com, and we will review and address the matter promptly.

Canada Health Minister Says She Is Not Considering Looser Nicotine Pouch Retail Rules as PMI-Linked Group Pushes for Wider Access
Canada Health Minister Says She Is Not Considering Looser Nicotine Pouch Retail Rules as PMI-Linked Group Pushes for Wider Access
Canadian Health Minister Marjorie Michel says she is not considering loosening retail restrictions on nicotine pouches. Canada regulates pouches containing 4 mg or less of nicotine per unit as non-prescription nicotine replacement therapy and requires newer NRT formats such as pouches to be sold from behind pharmacy counters. Meanwhile, Unsmoke Canada, linked to Philip Morris International's Canadian business, is pushing to allow pouches in convenience stores and other general retail outlets. Health Canada also acknowledges continued unauthorized sales, while recent research shows rising pouch use among Canadian youth aged 16 to 19.
Sep.24
Product | KT&G Launches lil HYBRID 3.0 Misty Rosé Edition II in South Korea With Two Pink Finishes at 88,000 Won
Product | KT&G Launches lil HYBRID 3.0 Misty Rosé Edition II in South Korea With Two Pink Finishes at 88,000 Won
South Korean tobacco company KT&G launched the limited-edition lil HYBRID 3.0 Misty Rosé Edition II on September 30, 2026, following the original Misty Rosé Edition introduced in November 2025. The new release comes in two pink finishes, Bloom Rosé and Viva Rosé, each priced at 88,000 won. Both versions initially went on sale through the lil Store online shop and lil MINIMALIUM flagship stores. From October 7, Bloom Rosé became available at approximately 1,500 lil Station retail outlets nationwide. The release retains the existing lil HYBRID 3.0 hybrid heated tobacco platform, with changes focused on exterior design and distribution.
product
Oct.10
Product | KIWI Launches Spark 2 and Spark 2 Pro in Germany, Two Hardware Tiers Share Backward-Compatible 2ml Pods
Product | KIWI Launches Spark 2 and Spark 2 Pro in Germany, Two Hardware Tiers Share Backward-Compatible 2ml Pods
KIWI has launched the Spark 2 and Spark 2 Pro refillable pod systems in Germany at official prices of €18 and €29, respectively. Spark 2 uses an 800mAh removable lithium-ion battery in a pen-style body, while Spark 2 Pro features a 1,400mAh removable battery, a box-shaped design and vibration feedback every 20 puffs. Both devices use the same 2ml Spark V2 pods in 0.8Ω and 1.2Ω versions, with AirSync airflow adjustment and a choice between Cotton Tips and conventional Drip Tips. The new pods also remain compatible with the original KIWI Spark.
News
Sep.29 by 2Firsts Perspectives
Spain Cigarette Volumes Fall 5.2% in August, BAT Drops 14.5%, JTI Gains Share; France Down 8.3% on Adjusted Basis
Spain Cigarette Volumes Fall 5.2% in August, BAT Drops 14.5%, JTI Gains Share; France Down 8.3% on Adjusted Basis
Spain's cigarette volumes declined 5.2% year over year in August 2026, according to government data cited by UBS and reported by Investing.com on October 7. British American Tobacco's volumes fell 14.5%, followed by Imperial Brands at 8.8%, Philip Morris International at 6.6% and Japan Tobacco at 4.6%. JTI was the only one of the four companies to gain cigarette market share, rising six basis points to 26.7%. In France, official customs data showed an unadjusted 3.7% decline in cigarette deliveries. Adjusting for the difference in delivery days produces a decline of approximately 8.3%, consistent with the UBS figure. The bank also estimated the earnings exposure of major tobacco companies to both markets.
Market
Oct.13
Special Report | Altria's NACS Booth Raises Questions Over U.S. Tobacco Advertising Warnings
Special Report | Altria's NACS Booth Raises Questions Over U.S. Tobacco Advertising Warnings
During its coverage of Altria's booth at NACS Show 2026, 2Firsts documented product displays that prompted questions about U.S. tobacco advertising warning requirements. Following public comments from a former FDA official, 2Firsts sought responses from Altria and independently consulted U.S. regulatory lawyer Azim Chowdhury. Altria maintained that its B2B communications complied with applicable laws, while Chowdhury explained that federal warning rules provide no general trade-show exemption for e-cigarettes and nicotine pouches. The special report examines the broader regulatory implications.
Nov.04
Japan's Heated Tobacco Use Rises From 0.1% to 14.9% Over a Decade as Growth Extends Beyond Cigarette Switching
Japan's Heated Tobacco Use Rises From 0.1% to 14.9% Over a Decade as Growth Extends Beyond Cigarette Switching
A decade-long study published in The Lancet Regional Health – Western Pacific found that heated tobacco product use in Japan increased from 0.1% in 2015 to 14.9% in 2025, although growth slowed after 2018. Switching from conventional cigarettes remained an important source of HTP uptake, while the contribution from previously non-current users increased. Approximately 56% of HTP users also smoked conventional cigarettes in 2025. Separate industry data show that Japan's heated tobacco sales reached 73.4 billion units in fiscal 2025, approaching conventional cigarette sales of 78.2 billion units.
SCIENCE
Nov.10