Readers' Comments on "Reassessing Smoore: Mistakes, Crisis, and the Way Forward"

Industry Insight by 2FIRSTS
Jan.04.2024
Readers' Comments on "Reassessing Smoore: Mistakes, Crisis, and the Way Forward"
2FIRSTS released an article titled "Reassessing Smoore: Mistakes, Crisis, and the Way Forward", sparking widespread discussion in the e-cigarette industry.

On January 3rd, 2FIRSTS published an in-depth article titled "Rethinking Smoore: Mistakes, crisis, and a way forward". The article immediately sparked widespread discussion within the e-cigarette industry.

 

2FIRSTS has conducted a comprehensive summary of various perspectives on the Smoore issue thus far. The aim is to provide readers with a more comprehensive viewpoint for further contemplation and discussion.

 

Below are the various perspectives: 

 

@migao: 

 

The missed opportunity in the disposable business and the late push with two major clients are closely related. Smoore mainly operates as an OEM business, meaning that no matter how great its technology is, it is in vain if customers do not utilize it. This inherent passivity in Smoore's role explains why it fell behind in the disposable market. Had BAT positioned themselves earlier in the disposable market, Smoore would have naturally kept up. After all, the technology required for disposable products is relatively low, and Smoore already possessed accumulated enough to meet the product demands.

 

Speculating further, it can be said that the tobacco industry in the UK and the US is not as quick to embrace disposables, not because they are unaware of the trend but rather because they are cautious about entering into cutthroat competition. Up until 2022, they may have held on to the hope that disposables would not gain popularity, considering the significant profit gap compared to pod-based systems. However, they eventually realized that they couldn't ignore the trend and had to personally engage in the market. Losing market share is more terrifying than sacrificing profits.

 

Therefore, based on the aforementioned points, it is not surprising that Smoore's lagging behind in the market carries a certain degree of expected sorrow.

 

The game of major client and the demand for optimizing supply chain costs for major clients have been clearly reflected in the past year in British American Tobacco and RELX. This year, British American Tobacco has placed 50% or even more of its disposable business with FirstUnion. Although they have introduced multiple new products this year, the main existing models and a new flagship model are now dominated by FirstUnion. This directly led to Smoore's failure to achieve its target of 4 billion in disposable business at the beginning of the year. If it had not been transferred to FirstUnion, Smoore's disposable business this year would have been around 50-60, but I estimate it will be around 35. RELX also experienced a similar situation, where the domestic market shifted from being solely supplied by Smoore to being shared by Smoore, FirstUnion, and ALD. As for the overseas market, I do not have the data, but I conservatively estimate that Smoore now accounts for less than 40%.

 

@Keepupthegoodwork:

 

The entire article fails to mention Smoore's compliance issues, such as PMTA, which is the fundamental reason why it has not entered the US market. In the European market, disposable companies have violated TPD rules by entering with a large number of products, which is also a significant reason why Smoore has not collaborated with these companies. Therefore, Smoore's current situation is largely due to various policy reasons, not its research and development efforts. Additionally, it should be noted that half of Smoore's research and development investment is allocated to HNB products, not solely disposable products, which the articles have failed to mention.

 

@999Roses:

 

In my impression, this seems to be the most detailed article analyzing Smoore. After reading it several times, I feel both disappointed by the setback of a giant and reassured by glimpses of hope. I am someone who believes in the power of time and believes in the order of the world. The road for e-cigarettes is still very long. The market will eventually move away from prioritizing growth data. At that time, the ultimate winner will be the one with the safest product and sufficient trust. There is a saying in the business world, "Don't compare who has a more glamorous life, but who can live longer." Yes, I believe Smoore is the company that will always be at the table.

 

Anonymous user:

 

Smoore has missed out on the best period of overseas development, which is both a strategic misjudgment and a result of their difficulty in ignoring external regulations. They are a company with long-term plans and have not made any fundamental mistakes in major decisions. However, China and overseas markets are two different playing fields, and therefore require two different approaches. Nevertheless, Smoore has once flourished, but it now appears increasingly quiet in the face of external capital speculation.

 

Anonymous User:

 

Smoore's investment is long-term and represents recognition of the regulatory trends surrounding e-cigarette compliance and the regulation of similar tobacco products. Due to requirements for compliance as a public company, Smoore cannot dramatically increase production orders. Additionally, as the tobacco industry is dominated by a few key players, Smoore must maintain strong relationships with these market leaders. In the short term, the e-cigarette market is not yet in a highly regulated era, so Smoore's second growth phase will not occur just yet. As a technology-driven company, Smoore must focus on iterating and innovating its vaporization technology, controlling factory costs, and betting on its new vaporization technology consumer products becoming popular. However, it is still too early to say whether these strategies will be successful.

 

It is even uncertain whether Smoore will remain standing until the day the mist clears.

 

An User on Xueqiu:

 

The analysis is sound, but it is unclear whether the author intentionally or unintentionally overlooked an important point - the importance of compliance and the impact of strong regulation on competition. RELX and Smoore's success was achieved in an environment without stringent regulation, which proved their capabilities as a manufacturer and brand. However, in the later years, the industry faced strong regulation, which noticeably affected major players like RELX and Smoore. On the other hand, new small and medium-sized manufacturers could take advantage of regulatory loopholes for penetration and development of new products, without facing the same restrictions. As a result, RELX and Smoore found themselves constrained within a very limited space, making the competition unequal. The decline in their market share, apart from not keeping up with e-cigarette consumer trends, can largely be attributed to this unfair competition. However, running fast doesn't guarantee running far. From a regulatory standpoint, e-cigarettes are burdened with "original sin." Therefore, compliance with regulations, legality, and ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) initiatives are the basic guarantees for companies to persist in the long run. RELX and Smoore possess much stronger capabilities in these aspects compared to other new players, although this often goes unnoticed.

 

We welcome news tips, article submissions, interview requests, or comments on this piece.

Please contact us at info@2firsts.com, or reach out to Alan Zhao, CEO of 2Firsts, on LinkedIn


Notice

1.  This article is intended solely for professional research purposes related to industry, technology, and policy. Any references to brands or products are made purely for objective description and do not constitute any form of endorsement, recommendation, or promotion by 2Firsts.

2.  The use of nicotine-containing products — including, but not limited to, cigarettes, e-cigarettes, nicotine pouchand heated tobacco products — carries significant health risks. Users are responsible for complying with all applicable laws and regulations in their respective jurisdictions.

3.  This article is not intended to serve as the basis for any investment decisions or financial advice. 2Firsts assumes no direct or indirect liability for any inaccuracies or errors in the content.

4.  Access to this article is strictly prohibited for individuals below the legal age in their jurisdiction.

 

Copyright

 

This article is either an original work created by 2Firsts or a reproduction from third-party sources with proper attribution. All copyrights and usage rights belong to 2Firsts or the original content provider. Unauthorized reproduction, distribution, or any other form of unauthorized use by any individual or organization is strictly prohibited. Violators will be held legally accountable.

For copyright-related inquiries, please contact: info@2firsts.com

 

AI Assistance Disclaimer

 

This article may have been enhanced using AI tools to improve translation and editorial efficiency. However, due to technical limitations, inaccuracies may occur. Readers are encouraged to refer to the cited sources for the most accurate information.

We welcome any corrections or feedback. Please contact us at: info@2firsts.com

Special report|Indonesia's Vape Industry Has 200 Manufacturers and $1.7 Billion in Investment. Could a Regulatory Divide Derail Its Rise as the World's No. 2 Manufacturing Hub After Shenzhen?
Special report|Indonesia's Vape Industry Has 200 Manufacturers and $1.7 Billion in Investment. Could a Regulatory Divide Derail Its Rise as the World's No. 2 Manufacturing Hub After Shenzhen?
Indonesia's Ministry of Industry said at a November 3, 2026, policy forum that the country has about 200 electronic cigarette companies, Rp31 trillion (approximately $1.71 billion) in cumulative industry investment and around 100,000 jobs across the supply chain. The National Narcotics Agency is seeking a comprehensive ban on vape use and circulation, while the industry ministry favors tighter import, product-standard and distribution controls. Indonesia exported approximately $518 million in vaping products in 2025, and Chinese manufacturers including Smoore, GEEKVAPE and Jinjia Group have established local operations. An international logistics specialist interviewed by 2Firsts said more Chinese vape companies began production in Indonesia from the second half of 2025, accompanied by increased shipments of manufacturing equipment and investment in logistics facilities. The regulatory debate comes as Indonesia expands its role in international vaping manufacturing.
Special Report
Nov.05
Vape Manufacturer Ispire Expands Malaysia Operations, Negotiates Southeast Asia OEM Deal as Nicotine Pouch and US Age-Gating Businesses Develop
Vape Manufacturer Ispire Expands Malaysia Operations, Negotiates Southeast Asia OEM Deal as Nicotine Pouch and US Age-Gating Businesses Develop
US-listed vaping technology and manufacturing company Ispire Technology reported fiscal first-quarter 2027 revenue of $27.5 million on November 9, 2026, down 9.3% year over year but up 3.2% sequentially. Gross margin recovered to 16.2%, while its net loss widened to $6.4 million from $3.3 million a year earlier. Management attributed the sales decline primarily to tighter European vaping regulation and reduced distributor orders. Ispire is expanding manufacturing in Malaysia and negotiating an OEM/ODM agreement with a Southeast Asian vaping brand, with an announcement anticipated in January 2027. The company estimates that Malaysian manufacturing offers an approximately 25% US tariff advantage over China-based production. However, it continues to purchase products from Shenzhen Yi Jia Technology Co., Ltd., a manufacturer controlled by its chairman, and reported $52 million in non-current related-party payables at September 30.
company
Nov.11 by 2Firsts Perspectives
UK Vape Tax Reshapes Costs: VPZ's £1.5 Million Plan, Totally Wicked's Three HMRC Approvals and VSL's Wholesale Challenge
UK Vape Tax Reshapes Costs: VPZ's £1.5 Million Plan, Totally Wicked's Three HMRC Approvals and VSL's Wholesale Challenge
Britain's new vaping excise duty, introduced on October 1, 2026, is changing how manufacturers, distributors and retailers manage production, inventory and tax compliance. Specialist vape retailer VPZ reportedly plans to invest up to £1.5 million in production and duty-stamp systems, following earlier plans for a fifth production line, bonded warehousing and 40 additional stores. Rival Totally Wicked says it has obtained three HMRC approvals covering manufacturing, duty-suspended storage and representation of overseas manufacturers. Wholesale distributor Vape Supplier Limited (VSL) has identified stock conversion costs, warehousing requirements and margin pressure among its business risks. The companies illustrate how different operating models are responding to Britain's new tax and product-traceability requirements.
Market
Nov.16
Japan Survey Finds 49.5% Would Cut Tobacco Use if Prices Rise, 64.6% Show Interest in Nicotine-Free Alternatives
Japan Survey Finds 49.5% Would Cut Tobacco Use if Prices Rise, 64.6% Show Interest in Nicotine-Free Alternatives
A September online survey commissioned by Japanese smoking-accessories company Lightec found that 49.5% of respondents would consider reducing tobacco use if prices rose further, while 25.1% would consider switching to cheaper brands and 14.5% would consider using or combining alternatives such as vapes and nicotine-free herbal sticks. Another 64.6% expressed some level of interest in such alternatives. The survey covered 1,088 respondents aged 20 to 70 and was conducted by a company that sells NICOLESS nicotine-free vaping and herbal-stick products, meaning its findings should not be treated as representative of Japan's smoking population.
DATA
Oct.12
Special Report|Virginia Vape Directory Shows Contrast Between Vuse and JUUL Pod Systems and CrossBar 20K, Loon Flavored Disposables
Special Report|Virginia Vape Directory Shows Contrast Between Vuse and JUUL Pod Systems and CrossBar 20K, Loon Flavored Disposables
A 2Firsts analysis of Virginia's liquid nicotine and vapor product certification directory identified 213 product records from 15 manufacturers. Companies associated with BAT, Altria, Imperial Brands, JTI and JUUL account for 127 entries. The directory also includes independent brands CrossBar 20K, Loon and Breeze. CrossBar advertises a 13mL disposable capable of up to 20,000 puffs, while Loon has 16 disposable entries featuring fruit, cooling and beverage-related flavors. Of all records, 120 are labeled as under FDA PMTA review. Virginia introduced revised penalties on October 1, 2026, including a minimum first-violation civil penalty of $5,000 per unlisted product, alongside new retail tobacco permitting requirements.
Regulations
Oct.30
Smoke-Free Business Hits 42% of Q2 Net Revenue as PMI’s First TNFD Report Covers Single-Use Electronics, Critical Raw Materials and IQOS Repairs
Smoke-Free Business Hits 42% of Q2 Net Revenue as PMI’s First TNFD Report Covers Single-Use Electronics, Critical Raw Materials and IQOS Repairs
Philip Morris International has published its first report aligned with the Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures, bringing its electronics supply chain and the use and end-of-life stages of smoke-free devices and consumables into its nature-related assessment. PMI said its smoke-free business accounted for about 42% of total net revenues in the second quarter of 2026. The report says non-circular electronic products, particularly single-use items, can increase consumption of limited natural resources and also details an IQOS repair pilot. A 2040 circularity scenario tests assumptions including a 50% reduction in product waste-related costs, 10% raw-material savings and a 25% substitution rate for refurbished products versus new products.
Sep.23