Altria and NJOY Sue ITC, Claim Judge Appointment Process Is Unconstitutional

Nov.10

Altria Group and its NJOY subsidiary have filed a lawsuit in Virginia federal court challenging the U.S. International Trade Commission’s process for appointing administrative law judges. The companies allege the system violates the U.S. Constitution and seek to halt an ITC patent investigation initiated by rival Juul.

Key Points

Altria and NJOY filed a constitutional challenge against the ITC’s appointment of ALJs.
The lawsuit seeks to halt a Juul-led patent investigation.
The companies say ITC judges’ appointment and removal processes violate Articles II and III.
Juul alleges NJOY’s vaping products infringe its vaporizer patent.
Case filed in Virginia’s Eastern District Court.

2Firsts, November 10, 2025 — According to Law360, Altria Group Inc. and its NJOY vaping unit sued the U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC) on Friday, arguing that the agency’s method of appointing administrative law judges (ALJs) is unconstitutional and asking a Virginia federal court to block a pending patent case filed by Juul Labs.

The companies contend that ITC ALJs are “inferior officers” who must be appointed by the president, a court, or a department head, rather than by the ITC chair alone. They further argue that the ITC’s appointment process and removal protections for judges violate the Constitution’s Appointments Clause and Article II.

Juul’s complaint, filed in August, accuses NJOY of importing and selling vaping devices that infringe its vaporizer patents. The ITC began investigating in September and assigned Administrative Law Judge Doris Johnson Hines to the case, with hearings scheduled through 2026.

Altria and NJOY also claim the ITC proceeding usurps judicial authority and deprives them of a jury trial under Article III and the Fifth and Seventh Amendments. The case is NJOY LLC et al. v. The International Trade Commission et al., No. 3:25-cv-00930, in the Eastern District of Virginia.

References:

[1] Altria, NJOY Rip 'Unconstitutional' ITC Patent Proceeding

Also Read:

[1] Altria Q3 2025 Earnings Report: Net Revenue of $6.072 Billion and Launch of on!PLUS in the U.S.

[2] Altria’s on!PLUS Nicotine Pouches Reportedly Available in U.S.; Users Say They Have Received Orders

[3] California Federal Judge Signals Likely Class Certification in Juul–Altria Antitrust Case

2FIRSTS Data Insight｜China’s Vape Exports to the U.S. Hit a Record $590 Million: A Peak Driven by Enforcement Cycles, Not Real Demand

China’s vape exports to the U.S. surged to a record $590 million in October 2025—nearly double the usual monthly level and pushing the U.S. share above 50% of China’s global shipments.But the spike was not driven by demand. Instead, it reflected a temporary release created by tightened U.S. enforcement, a collapsed logistics pathway, and a bullwhip-style surge in replenishment.The peak signals more volatility ahead, not recovery.

Special Report

Nov.24

Coral Springs, Florida Moves to Extend Ban on New Vape Shops as Number of Existing Stores Reaches 23

Coral Springs, Florida is considering extending its six-month moratorium on new smoke and vape shops as it works to finalize zoning rules and regulatory measures in response to a rapid increase in such retailers in recent years. The city is already home to 23 smoke and vape shops.