Debate Continues Over Legality and Benefits of E-cigarettes

Sep.05.2022
Debate Continues Over Legality and Benefits of E-cigarettes
The debate continues on whether e-cigarette bans will make them equivalent to traditional cigarettes, as courts continue to discuss their legality.

As the legal use of electronic cigarettes continues to be a topic of debate in court, the discussion over whether a ban would simply transform e-cigarettes into regular cigarettes also persists.


Following the Federal Appeals Court's decision in June to block the FDA's ban, Juul is now able to continue selling its electronic cigarettes. However, in order to remain on the market, the company must prove that its products benefit public health. Essentially, this means proving that adult smokers who use the e-cigarettes may quit or reduce smoking, while youth are unlikely to become addicted to them.


The federal appeals court for the third time rejected a petition from an Illinois-based electronic cigarette manufacturer seeking a review of the FDA's marketing refusal order. A panel of three judges in the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the FDA, dismissing the appeal from Gripum LLC.


Elizabeth Hicks, a US affairs analyst at Consumer Choice Center, warns that banning flavors in electronic cigarettes and tobacco products could lead consumers to revert back to smoking combustible tobacco: "Around 12% of adults reported smoking in 2020, but we can certainly expect that number to increase.


Hicks stated that with more and more individuals smoking, taxpayers in Illinois will ultimately have to foot the bill.


She said this will ultimately lead to an increase in healthcare costs related to smoking, which already costs taxpayers in Illinois over $1.9 billion annually.


Meredith Berkman is working with parents who are against the use of e-cigarettes. They are calling for the removal of all e-cigarettes from the market. According to Berkman, her organization is receiving help from an Illinois senator.


For years, Dick Durbin has been battling the tobacco industry, calling on the FDA to remove these products from the market," Berkman said.


As schools across the country begin their academic year, the organization Berkman is offering a "Guide to E-cigarette Use in Schools" to help parents identify signs of e-cigarette use and provide resources for those who need help quitting.


Disclaimer: 1. This article is compiled from third-party sources and is only meant for industry exchange and learning. 2. The views expressed in this article do not represent the views of 2FIRSTS, and 2FIRSTS is unable to confirm the authenticity and accuracy of the article's content. The compilation of this article is only intended for industry exchange and research. 3. Due to limited compilation capabilities, the compiled article may not fully reflect the original text, and the original text should be relied upon. 4. Regarding any domestic, Hong Kong, Macau, Taiwan, and foreign statements and positions, 2FIRSTS is fully aligned with the Chinese government. 5. The copyright of the compiled information belongs to the original media and author. If there is any infringement, please contact us for removal.


This document has been generated through artificial intelligence translation and is provided solely for the purposes of industry discourse and learning. Please note that the intellectual property rights of the content belong to the original media source or author. Owing to certain limitations in the translation process, there may be discrepancies between the translated text and the original content. We recommend referring to the original source for complete accuracy. In case of any inaccuracies, we invite you to reach out to us with corrections. If you believe any content has infringed upon your rights, please contact us immediately for its removal.

Imperial Brands Launches Red, Gold and Silver iD Heated Tobacco Sticks in Europe
Imperial Brands Launches Red, Gold and Silver iD Heated Tobacco Sticks in Europe
Imperial Brands PLC said on February 18, 2026 that it has launched its new Red, Gold and Silver iD heated tobacco sticks in Greece and Poland, with a broader rollout across Europe planned for 2026.
Feb.18
West Virginia Governor Signs Bill Directing USD 2.9 Million From Juul Settlement to Youth Tobacco Prevention
West Virginia Governor Signs Bill Directing USD 2.9 Million From Juul Settlement to Youth Tobacco Prevention
The American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network said West Virginia Governor Patrick Morrisey has signed House Bill 5691 into law, directing USD 2.9 million from the Juul settlement to youth tobacco prevention and programs that help people quit. The bill is a supplemental appropriation measure, and the Legislature’s bill history shows it passed the House on March 11, passed the Senate on March 13 and was sent to the governor on March 18.
Mar.20 by 2FIRSTS.ai
STMA Issues Trial Credit Management Rules for E-Cigarette Manufacturers and Wholesalers
STMA Issues Trial Credit Management Rules for E-Cigarette Manufacturers and Wholesalers
Mar.26 by 2FIRSTS.ai
Fiscal benefit, not health, strongest indicator for vape bans – Contributed by Samrat Chowdhery
Fiscal benefit, not health, strongest indicator for vape bans – Contributed by Samrat Chowdhery
Data shows 75% of nations with state stakes in tobacco trade ban modern substitutes compared to 10% in the free-market group. What is driving these divergent regulations?
Feb.04
PMI Faces Setback in India: Global Regulatory Fragmentation Complicates Its Smoke-Free Transition
PMI Faces Setback in India: Global Regulatory Fragmentation Complicates Its Smoke-Free Transition
India has reaffirmed its 2019 ban on e-cigarettes and heated tobacco devices, effectively blocking Philip Morris International (PMI) from launching IQOS in the country despite years of lobbying. Together with Taiwan, China’s conditional opening of heated tobacco products, and Japan’s planned 2026 excise tax hikes, these moves highlight increasingly divergent national regulatory pathways—an external uncertainty shaping PMI’s smoke-free growth trajectory.
Feb.12
Nebraska Lawmakers Consider Major Tax Hikes on Cigarettes, Vapes and Other Nicotine Products
Nebraska Lawmakers Consider Major Tax Hikes on Cigarettes, Vapes and Other Nicotine Products
Nebraska lawmakers are considering two tax bills targeting nicotine products. LB1124 would raise the cigarette tax from $0.64 to $1.64 per pack, while LB1238 would shift cigarettes to a 30% tax on the retailer’s purchase price and increase taxes on alternative nicotine and other tobacco products to 30%. The commentary argues the hikes could raise consumer costs, pressure small retailers, and increase cross-border shopping and illicit market activity.
Feb.04 by 2FIRSTS.ai