US Supreme Court Overturns Precedent, Impacting E-Cigarette Industry and FDA

Regulations by 2FIRSTS.ai
Jul.03.2024
US Supreme Court Overturns Precedent, Impacting E-Cigarette Industry and FDA
US Supreme Court overturns decades-old precedent, potentially changing FDA's power in regulating e-cigarette industry.

According to VAPING360, the US Supreme Court has overturned a decades-old precedent that nearly gave federal agencies an insurmountable advantage in defending their regulations against legal challenges. The court's decision in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo (and a related case, Relentless v. Department of Commerce) could impact pending challenges in the e-cigarette industry against FDA regulations, potentially leading to changes in how the FDA regulates e-cigarette products.

 

The Supreme Court's decision overturned the Chevron doctrine based on the 1984 case of Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council. The Chevron doctrine held that as long as an agency's interpretation is reasonable, the court should defer to the "expertise" of federal agencies in interpreting ambiguous laws that the agency needs to implement.

 

This decision could potentially impact legal challenges to the FDA's interpretation of the 2009 Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act (TCA), which grants the agency broad authority to regulate nicotine and tobacco products. The TCA does not specifically mention e-cigarette products, which were not on the market in the United States when the law was passed.

 

However, the FDA used a provision in the Tobacco Control Act to issue the 2016 "Deeming Rule," granting the agency regulatory authority over e-cigarettes, nicotine pouches, and other products not described in the 2009 legislation. The "Deeming Rule" establishes a system for manufacturers to submit market applications for e-cigarettes and other nicotine products.

 

When the FDA received a large number of pre-market tobacco applications (PMTAs) from small e-cigarette manufacturers and realized it was unable to individually consider them as required by the Tobacco Control Act (TCA), the agency created the so-called "deadly defects" system, allowing it to issue millions of marketing denial orders (MDOs) for flavored e-cigarette products without conducting actual scientific review.

 

In a friend-of-the-court brief submitted to the Supreme Court last year by a group of e-cigarette companies and trade organizations, industry lawyers explained how the FDA has used Chevron deference to create a maze of an elusive (essentially undefined) standard.

 

They wrote that the FDA "has taken a one-size-fits-all approach, which has dramatically tipped the scales in one direction, effectively banning all non-tobacco flavors (such as mint and fruit) of ENDS products, and in the process, focusing primarily on underage use, at the expense of adult smokers. The FDA implemented this de facto ban not by requiring Congress to amend the TCA or by establishing tobacco product standards through public notice and comment rulemaking procedures as required by the APA, but by issuing a regulation that is not based on the text, structure, and context of the TCA.

 

Due to the courts' tendency to view most challenges to federal agency power through the lens of Chevron deference, federal district and appellate courts have granted the FDA broad latitude to effectively ban all flavors of e-cigarettes, even when applications have been submitted, by improvising standards.

 

The decision of the Supreme Court in "Loper Bright" will impact how Congress writes laws, how federal agencies enforce laws, and how courts interpret laws. It could result in future court decisions partially limiting the FDA's Tobacco Products Center, forcing tobacco regulatory agencies to carefully consider the interests of adult consumers when reviewing market applications.

 

We welcome news tips, article submissions, interview requests, or comments on this piece.

Please contact us at info@2firsts.com, or reach out to Alan Zhao, CEO of 2Firsts, on LinkedIn


Notice

1.  This article is intended solely for professional research purposes related to industry, technology, and policy. Any references to brands or products are made purely for objective description and do not constitute any form of endorsement, recommendation, or promotion by 2Firsts.

2.  The use of nicotine-containing products — including, but not limited to, cigarettes, e-cigarettes, nicotine pouchand heated tobacco products — carries significant health risks. Users are responsible for complying with all applicable laws and regulations in their respective jurisdictions.

3.  This article is not intended to serve as the basis for any investment decisions or financial advice. 2Firsts assumes no direct or indirect liability for any inaccuracies or errors in the content.

4.  Access to this article is strictly prohibited for individuals below the legal age in their jurisdiction.

 

Copyright

 

This article is either an original work created by 2Firsts or a reproduction from third-party sources with proper attribution. All copyrights and usage rights belong to 2Firsts or the original content provider. Unauthorized reproduction, distribution, or any other form of unauthorized use by any individual or organization is strictly prohibited. Violators will be held legally accountable.

For copyright-related inquiries, please contact: info@2firsts.com

 

AI Assistance Disclaimer

 

This article may have been enhanced using AI tools to improve translation and editorial efficiency. However, due to technical limitations, inaccuracies may occur. Readers are encouraged to refer to the cited sources for the most accurate information.

We welcome any corrections or feedback. Please contact us at: info@2firsts.com

Special Report | How Capital Is Reassessing the Global Tobacco and Modern Nicotine Industry: Lessons from a New York Forum
Special Report | How Capital Is Reassessing the Global Tobacco and Modern Nicotine Industry: Lessons from a New York Forum
Capital is reassessing the global tobacco and modern nicotine industry as heated tobacco, vaping and nicotine pouches reshape demand, profitability and regulation. At the 2026 New Approaches Summit in New York, investors and analysts examined whether smoke-free growth can sustain earnings, how regulation shapes startup value, and whether shareholder engagement can be more effective than divestment. The debate points to a broader shift: tobacco transition is increasingly becoming a capital-allocation, governance and valuation question.
Capital Markets
Oct.05
Special Report|From CrossBar 20K to 6-Methyl Nicotine KUMI: Two Routes Into U.S. State Vape Directories?
Special Report|From CrossBar 20K to 6-Methyl Nicotine KUMI: Two Routes Into U.S. State Vape Directories?
Several U.S. states have incorporated the September 9, 2020 PMTA filing deadline into eligibility rules for certain vaping products. CrossBar 20K drew attention after appearing on Pennsylvania's 163-entry directory. A broader 2Firsts investigation found that related registration businesses also listed KUMI and CROSSBAR SIX products, with 171 KUMI-related entries across Louisiana, Nebraska and Wisconsin. Corporate records link Scott Silverman to Blue Nine LLC and VR Products I LLC. PMTA compliance expert Mr. K said historical applications and nicotine-analogue products may offer two different approaches to state-directory access.
Regulations
Oct.26
Why Does JPMorgan Favor BAT Over Philip Morris Despite Forecasting Slower Growth of 3.9% Versus 6.2%?
Why Does JPMorgan Favor BAT Over Philip Morris Despite Forecasting Slower Growth of 3.9% Versus 6.2%?
JPMorgan resumed equity research coverage of British American Tobacco (BAT), Philip Morris International (PMI) and Imperial Brands in November 2026, assigning BAT an Overweight rating and the other two companies Neutral ratings. The bank forecasts like-for-like sales growth of 3.9% for BAT and 6.2% for PMI in 2027, but estimates the two companies will trade at approximately 11 times and 21 times 2027 earnings, respectively. JPMorgan cited BAT's improving position in US nicotine pouches and vaping products as a driver of its investment outlook. BAT reported a 220% constant-currency increase in US modern oral nicotine revenue in the first half of 2026, while PMI's ZYN US shipments returned to growth in the third quarter. Imperial expects NGPs to represent 4% to 5% of sales and has expanded its oral portfolio through acquisitions.
Capital Markets
Nov.12
South Korea's Tobacco Plan Excludes 6-Methyl Nicotine as Customs Tightens Import Controls and Analog Liquid Imports Fall 83%
South Korea's Tobacco Plan Excludes 6-Methyl Nicotine as Customs Tightens Import Controls and Analog Liquid Imports Fall 83%
South Korea's government unveiled its first Tobacco Harm Management Basic Plan for 2027–2031 on October 29, 2026, proposing broader testing of vaping and heated tobacco products while excluding nicotine analogs such as 6-methyl nicotine. Synthetic nicotine came under tobacco regulation on April 24, and a June investigation found 6-methyl nicotine in 12 liquid inhalation products marketed as nicotine-free. Customs data released in September showed that imports of nicotine analog solutions fell 83.3%, from 12 metric tons in January–April to 2 metric tons in May–August. By September 20, imports had reached approximately 15 metric tons for the year, with 99.99% originating from China. Customs authorities have tightened pre-clearance testing and supply-chain documentation requirements, while the MFDS expects to complete its assessment of nicotine analog hazards by the end of 2026.
Regulations
Nov.04
Swedish Match Faces Broader Labeling Order After ZYN Inspection, Documents Obtained by 2Firsts Show
Swedish Match Faces Broader Labeling Order After ZYN Inspection, Documents Obtained by 2Firsts Show
Documents obtained by 2Firsts show that Sweden's Public Health Agency ordered Swedish Match to revise ingredient labels beyond the five ZYN products inspected. The dispute centers on whether flavoring ingredients must be individually disclosed, with Swedish Match citing trade-secret protection and the regulator insisting on full ingredient disclosure. The company faces a conditional penalty of SEK 2 million per month for noncompliance. As of October 22, the agency had received no appeal, despite the company's stated intention to challenge the decision.
Oct.22
Malaysia's Poisons Board Backs New Vape Nicotine Exemption After Unanimously Opposing 2023 Proposal
Malaysia's Poisons Board Backs New Vape Nicotine Exemption After Unanimously Opposing 2023 Proposal
Malaysia's Poisons Board has endorsed Health Minister Dzulkefly Ahmad's proposal to exempt liquid nicotine used in vaping products from the Poisons List, according to a November 2, 2026, report by CodeBlue. The Board unanimously opposed a similar proposal in 2023, but the government proceeded with the exemption. The Kuala Lumpur High Court invalidated the 2023 decision in May 2026, and the government withdrew its appeal in August. No new ministerial order has been published. The development raises questions about the interaction between Malaysia's two regulatory frameworks and the treatment of RM354.51 million in excise duties collected on e-cigarette and vape products between May 2023 and June 11, 2026.
Regulations
Nov.03