US Supreme Court Overturns Precedent, Impacting E-Cigarette Industry and FDA

Regulations by 2FIRSTS.ai
Jul.03.2024
US Supreme Court Overturns Precedent, Impacting E-Cigarette Industry and FDA
US Supreme Court overturns decades-old precedent, potentially changing FDA's power in regulating e-cigarette industry.

According to VAPING360, the US Supreme Court has overturned a decades-old precedent that nearly gave federal agencies an insurmountable advantage in defending their regulations against legal challenges. The court's decision in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo (and a related case, Relentless v. Department of Commerce) could impact pending challenges in the e-cigarette industry against FDA regulations, potentially leading to changes in how the FDA regulates e-cigarette products.

 

The Supreme Court's decision overturned the Chevron doctrine based on the 1984 case of Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council. The Chevron doctrine held that as long as an agency's interpretation is reasonable, the court should defer to the "expertise" of federal agencies in interpreting ambiguous laws that the agency needs to implement.

 

This decision could potentially impact legal challenges to the FDA's interpretation of the 2009 Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act (TCA), which grants the agency broad authority to regulate nicotine and tobacco products. The TCA does not specifically mention e-cigarette products, which were not on the market in the United States when the law was passed.

 

However, the FDA used a provision in the Tobacco Control Act to issue the 2016 "Deeming Rule," granting the agency regulatory authority over e-cigarettes, nicotine pouches, and other products not described in the 2009 legislation. The "Deeming Rule" establishes a system for manufacturers to submit market applications for e-cigarettes and other nicotine products.

 

When the FDA received a large number of pre-market tobacco applications (PMTAs) from small e-cigarette manufacturers and realized it was unable to individually consider them as required by the Tobacco Control Act (TCA), the agency created the so-called "deadly defects" system, allowing it to issue millions of marketing denial orders (MDOs) for flavored e-cigarette products without conducting actual scientific review.

 

In a friend-of-the-court brief submitted to the Supreme Court last year by a group of e-cigarette companies and trade organizations, industry lawyers explained how the FDA has used Chevron deference to create a maze of an elusive (essentially undefined) standard.

 

They wrote that the FDA "has taken a one-size-fits-all approach, which has dramatically tipped the scales in one direction, effectively banning all non-tobacco flavors (such as mint and fruit) of ENDS products, and in the process, focusing primarily on underage use, at the expense of adult smokers. The FDA implemented this de facto ban not by requiring Congress to amend the TCA or by establishing tobacco product standards through public notice and comment rulemaking procedures as required by the APA, but by issuing a regulation that is not based on the text, structure, and context of the TCA.

 

Due to the courts' tendency to view most challenges to federal agency power through the lens of Chevron deference, federal district and appellate courts have granted the FDA broad latitude to effectively ban all flavors of e-cigarettes, even when applications have been submitted, by improvising standards.

 

The decision of the Supreme Court in "Loper Bright" will impact how Congress writes laws, how federal agencies enforce laws, and how courts interpret laws. It could result in future court decisions partially limiting the FDA's Tobacco Products Center, forcing tobacco regulatory agencies to carefully consider the interests of adult consumers when reviewing market applications.

 

We welcome news tips, article submissions, interview requests, or comments on this piece.

Please contact us at info@2firsts.com, or reach out to Alan Zhao, CEO of 2Firsts, on LinkedIn


Notice

1.  This article is intended solely for professional research purposes related to industry, technology, and policy. Any references to brands or products are made purely for objective description and do not constitute any form of endorsement, recommendation, or promotion by 2Firsts.

2.  The use of nicotine-containing products — including, but not limited to, cigarettes, e-cigarettes, nicotine pouchand heated tobacco products — carries significant health risks. Users are responsible for complying with all applicable laws and regulations in their respective jurisdictions.

3.  This article is not intended to serve as the basis for any investment decisions or financial advice. 2Firsts assumes no direct or indirect liability for any inaccuracies or errors in the content.

4.  Access to this article is strictly prohibited for individuals below the legal age in their jurisdiction.

 

Copyright

 

This article is either an original work created by 2Firsts or a reproduction from third-party sources with proper attribution. All copyrights and usage rights belong to 2Firsts or the original content provider. Unauthorized reproduction, distribution, or any other form of unauthorized use by any individual or organization is strictly prohibited. Violators will be held legally accountable.

For copyright-related inquiries, please contact: info@2firsts.com

 

AI Assistance Disclaimer

 

This article may have been enhanced using AI tools to improve translation and editorial efficiency. However, due to technical limitations, inaccuracies may occur. Readers are encouraged to refer to the cited sources for the most accurate information.

We welcome any corrections or feedback. Please contact us at: info@2firsts.com

Japan Survey Finds 49.5% Would Cut Tobacco Use if Prices Rise, 64.6% Show Interest in Nicotine-Free Alternatives
Japan Survey Finds 49.5% Would Cut Tobacco Use if Prices Rise, 64.6% Show Interest in Nicotine-Free Alternatives
A September online survey commissioned by Japanese smoking-accessories company Lightec found that 49.5% of respondents would consider reducing tobacco use if prices rose further, while 25.1% would consider switching to cheaper brands and 14.5% would consider using or combining alternatives such as vapes and nicotine-free herbal sticks. Another 64.6% expressed some level of interest in such alternatives. The survey covered 1,088 respondents aged 20 to 70 and was conducted by a company that sells NICOLESS nicotine-free vaping and herbal-stick products, meaning its findings should not be treated as representative of Japan's smoking population.
DATA
Oct.12
Virginia Tobacco Retail Permit Takes Effect October 1, Covering Vapes as More Than 3,000 Businesses Apply in September
Virginia Tobacco Retail Permit Takes Effect October 1, Covering Vapes as More Than 3,000 Businesses Apply in September
Virginia's new retail tobacco permit system took effect October 1, requiring sellers of vapes, nicotine products and related devices and accessories to obtain a Retail Tobacco Permit for each business location. Virginia ABC said more than 3,000 businesses applied in September alone, creating a processing backlog. Qualifying applicants that filed before October 1 may temporarily operate under a Letter of Authorization. The new store-level permit also sits alongside Virginia's existing vape product directory, where sales of unlisted liquid nicotine or nicotine vapor products can trigger civil penalties starting at $5,000.
Regulations
Oct.03
EU Tobacco Tax Reform Stalls as Malta Withholds Support Despite Backing From 26 States
EU Tobacco Tax Reform Stalls as Malta Withholds Support Despite Backing From 26 States
EU finance ministers failed to reach agreement on tobacco excise reform at the November 9, 2026 Economic and Financial Affairs Council (ECOFIN) meeting in Brussels. The Irish Council presidency's compromise secured support from 26 of the EU's 27 member states, but Malta withheld consent, preventing the Council from reaching a general approach requiring unanimity. The reform would raise minimum taxes on conventional tobacco and bring e-cigarette liquids, heated tobacco and nicotine pouches into a common EU minimum excise framework. Finland and Estonia accepted further concessions during the meeting, while the presidency proposed separating the inclusion of nicotine pouches in the framework from setting their precise minimum tax rates. Another compromise would allow ten qualifying member states until 2036 to meet certain tobacco excise requirements. Ireland intends to continue negotiations in December.
Regulations
Nov.11
Special Report | How Capital Is Reassessing the Global Tobacco and Modern Nicotine Industry: Lessons from a New York Forum
Special Report | How Capital Is Reassessing the Global Tobacco and Modern Nicotine Industry: Lessons from a New York Forum
Capital is reassessing the global tobacco and modern nicotine industry as heated tobacco, vaping and nicotine pouches reshape demand, profitability and regulation. At the 2026 New Approaches Summit in New York, investors and analysts examined whether smoke-free growth can sustain earnings, how regulation shapes startup value, and whether shareholder engagement can be more effective than divestment. The debate points to a broader shift: tobacco transition is increasingly becoming a capital-allocation, governance and valuation question.
Capital Markets
Oct.05
Indonesia's Influential Islamic Body MUI Urges Vape Permit Freeze, Raising Uncertainty for 200 Manufacturers
Indonesia's Influential Islamic Body MUI Urges Vape Permit Freeze, Raising Uncertainty for 200 Manufacturers
Indonesia's Ulema Council (MUI) published Fatwa No. 131/2026 on November 9, declaring electronic cigarette use, production and trade haram under Islamic religious rules. The council urged the Industry Ministry to prohibit the issuance of vape industry permits and review licensing policies, while calling on the president and parliament to enact a comprehensive ban. On November 10, the Constitutional Court heard a challenge to provisions of the 2023 Health Law seeking a prohibition on vape production, importation, distribution and use. The Health Ministry said on November 11 it was studying stronger restrictions, including a possible ban on circulation, while industry association APVI called for tighter oversight rather than a total ban. Indonesia's Industry Ministry previously estimated the sector comprises about 200 companies, Rp31 trillion ($1.7 billion) in cumulative investment and approximately 100,000 supply-chain jobs. No nationwide statutory ban has been enacted.
Regulations
Nov.12
Product | PMI Launches TEREA Black Mint Pearl in Japan, Adding First Capsule Variant to Black Range With Nationwide Rollout From October 19
Product | PMI Launches TEREA Black Mint Pearl in Japan, Adding First Capsule Variant to Black Range With Nationwide Rollout From October 19
Philip Morris Japan (PMJ) launched TEREA Black Mint Pearl on October 15, 2026, introducing the first capsule-equipped heated tobacco stick in the TEREA Black range for IQOS ILUMA devices. The product combines a strong menthol profile with a crushable mint capsule and is priced at ¥640 per 20-stick pack, including tax. Sales began at four IQOS stores and selected retail partners on October 15, with distribution expanding to convenience stores and other tobacco retailers nationwide from October 19. The launch brings Japan's TEREA portfolio to 28 variants, including 21 menthol-related products, or 75% of the range.
product
Oct.16 by 2Firsts Perspectives