Legal Battle Over E-Cigarette Ban: Constitutionality Challenge in Kentucky

Regulations by 2FIRSTS.ai
Jul.09.2024
Legal Battle Over E-Cigarette Ban: Constitutionality Challenge in Kentucky
Kentuckylantern reported on July 8 that Judge Thomas Wingate heard a case questioning the constitutionality of a law banning e-cigarette sales.

According to Kentucky Lantern's report on July 8th, Judge Thomas Wingate of the Franklin Circuit Court presided over a case on Monday (the 8th) questioning the constitutionality of a law banning the sale of certain e-cigarette products.

 

The defendants in the case, Allyson Taylor, the Director of the Alcohol Beverage Control Board in the state of Kentucky, and Secretary of State Michael Adams, have filed a motion to dismiss the case.

 

If Governor Whitaker approves this request, the plaintiffs, including the Kentucky E-Cigarette Retailers Association, the Kentucky Cannabis Association, and four e-cigarette sales shops, will appeal the decision. The plaintiffs have also filed a request for the court to make a judgment. However, the case is far from being resolved. Whitaker stated that he will need "some time" to review the matter.

 

This lawsuit centers around House Bill 11, which was passed in the legislative assembly in 2024. Supporters of the bill argue that it is a way to curb the use of e-cigarettes by minors by restricting the sale of "authorized products" or products that have obtained a "safe harbor certification" based on guidelines from the US FDA. Opponents argue that this will harm small businesses and lead to monopolies by large retailers.

 

According to records from the Legislative Ethics Commission, the tobacco giant Altria (previously known as Philip Morris) has lobbied for legislation in Kentucky and other states. The company has also entered the e-cigarette market, selling a variety of FDA-approved e-cigarette products.

 

Greg Troutman, the lawyer for the Kentucky Smoke Free Association, expressed to the judge on Monday that one of the many issues with the new law is how it defines "vapor products" and "other substances," lumping e-cigarettes and marijuana products together. He believes that this combination makes the law too broad and arbitrary, and it does not adhere to the constitution.

 

Troutman argued that the title of the bill, "The Nicotine Products Act," does not accurately represent the content of the legislation.

 

Assistant Attorney Lindsey Keiser rebutted by saying that headlines do not need to fully summarize the content of the bill.

 

It is a long-established fact that headlines do not need to include all the items contained in the bill.

 

The limited number of FDA approvals signifies concerns about these products. Therefore, Kentucky has ample reason to say, "If the FDA is only approving such a limited number, we should also strive to minimize the number approved.

 

Trotman argued that the state's regulations are flawed because they are built upon a flawed federal system.

 

Our state program was established before the federal program, which has itself been found arbitrary by at least two federal courts.

 

Notice

1. This article is provided exclusively for professional research purposes related to industry, technology and policy. Any reference to brands or products is made solely for the purpose of objective description and does not constitute an endorsement, recommendation, or promotion of any brand or product.

2. The use of nicotine products, including but not limited to cigarettes, e-cigarettes, and heated tobacco products, is associated with significant health risks. Users are required to comply with all relevant laws and regulations in their respective jurisdictions.

3. This article is strictly restricted from being accessed or viewed by individuals under the legal age.

Copyright

This article is either an original work by 2Firsts or a reproduction from third-party sources with the original source clearly indicated. The copyright and usage rights of this article belong to 2Firsts or the original source. Unauthorized reproduction, distribution, or any other unauthorized use of this article by any entity or individual is strictly prohibited. Violators will be held legally responsible. For copyright-related matters, please contact: info@2firsts.com

AI Assistance Disclaimer

This article may have utilized AI to enhance translation and editing efficiency. However, due to technical limitations, errors may occur. Readers are advised to refer to the sources provided for more accurate information.

This article should not be used as a basis for any investment decisions or advice, and 2Firsts assumes no direct or indirect liability for any errors in the content.

JTI Reports 14.4% Revenue Growth in Q1 2023
JTI Reports 14.4% Revenue Growth in Q1 2023
Japan Tobacco (JTI) reports Q1 revenue of 665.3 billion yen ($6.1 billion), a 14.4% YoY increase.
May.03 by 2FIRSTS.ai
2Firsts Co-Founder & CEO Alan Zhao in Exclusive Interview with Tobacco Asia: The Second Anniversary of China's E-Cigarette Regulatory Policy
2Firsts Co-Founder & CEO Alan Zhao in Exclusive Interview with Tobacco Asia: The Second Anniversary of China's E-Cigarette Regulatory Policy
Alan Zhao, the co-founder and CEO of 2Firsts, has over 10 years of experience in the traditional tobacco and NGP industry. Founded only a few years ago, 2Firsts.com has quickly become a globally leading media and consultancy platform with a declared focus on all matters NGP.
Special Report
Sep.09 by Thomas Schmid from Tobacco Asia, edited by Sophia
Trends and Regulations in the UK and EU Electronic Cigarette Industry
Trends and Regulations in the UK and EU Electronic Cigarette Industry
The 6th Normative Development Summit for the Electronic Cigarette Industry was held in Shenzhen on June 15th, 2022. The summit featured discussions on industry trends and market regulation policies.
Jun.15 by 2FIRSTS.ai
Lack of Professionalism in KT&G's Board of Directors
Lack of Professionalism in KT&G's Board of Directors
According to a report by South Korean Economic Daily, there is a lack of expertise among external directors at KT&G, as many are not industry professionals and have failed to address major issues.
Business
Jan.23 by 2FIRSTS.ai
Market Research: Large-Puff Pod Systems Dominate Malaysia Market, with Vapetape and Unplug as Bestsellers
Market Research: Large-Puff Pod Systems Dominate Malaysia Market, with Vapetape and Unplug as Bestsellers
Asian International New Tobacco Expo (ANTY EXPO) held in Malaysia, showcasing large pod system products dominating the market.
Market
Sep.13 by 2FIRSTS
ITC terminates investigation on Kimsun in e-cigarette dispute
ITC terminates investigation on Kimsun in e-cigarette dispute
ITC terminates investigation on disposable e-cigarette devices, issuing settlement order to Kimsun in 337 case.
Sep.25 by 2FIRSTS.ai