U.S. ITC Reopens PAX Labs Case Against STIIIZY, ALD; Domestic Industry Status at Center of Dispute

May.20
U.S. ITC Reopens PAX Labs Case Against STIIIZY, ALD; Domestic Industry Status at Center of Dispute
The U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC) has announced a partial review of a key ruling in PAX Labs' patent infringement case against STIIIZY and ALD, focusing on whether the economic prong of the "domestic industry" requirement was properly assessed. While the commission previously found some of PAX's patents valid and infringed, it ruled that PAX had not demonstrated sufficient U.S. economic investment to establish a domestic industry, and therefore did not find a violation.

Basic Information Overview:

 

1.Case Summary: 

·Parties involved: PAX Labs (appellant) suing STIIIZY and ALD (ALD, the defendant).

·Products involved in the case: oil steaming vaporization device (e-cigarette, battery, pod, etc.).

·Jurisdiction: United States International Trade Commission (ITC).

·Involved patents: U.S. Patent Numbers 11,369,756, 11,369,757, 11,766,527, and 11,759,580, relating to leak-proof pod and related equipment technology.

 

2.The core accusation:

·Patent infringement: PAX Labs alleges that STIIIZY and its manufacturer ALD have violated its four technology patents.

·Patent Scope: These patents concern the design of leak-proof structures and atomization system components for e-cigarette devices.

·Domestic industry clause controversy: According to Section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930, the ITC must determine if the complainant constitutes a "domestic industry" in the United States. A previous ruling by an administrative judge found that PAX Labs did not meet this economic requirement, resulting in a judgment that no infringement had occurred.

 

3.Progress of the case

·March 6, 2025: An Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) issued a final initial determination (FID) in the case, finding that the accused products did in fact infringe the patent and that the patent was valid. However, it was determined that PAX Labs did not meet the "domestic industry economic requirement," so no violation was found.

·May 2025: ITC announces a partial review of the ruling, focusing specifically on the determination of "economic elements" in the domestic industry clause. ITC points out that the administrative judge mistakenly applied a restrictive view that investments made before patent authorization do not qualify as recognizable investments in the domestic industry. The ruling is overturned and the case is remanded for further review.

·Further review plan: The ITC will wait for clarification on domestic industry issues before deciding on whether the accused products infringe on the '580 patent and if redesigning the products constitutes infringement.

·Case background: In January 2024, PAX Labs initiated a lawsuit accusing STIIIZY and ALD of selling e-cigarette devices in the U.S. using manufacturing methods similar to their patents.

 


 

Recently, the United States International Trade Commission (ITC) announced that it will partially review the preliminary ruling made by an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) in a patent infringement case involving vaporization devices (commonly referred to as e-cigarettes), and has decided to remand the key determination regarding "domestic industry economic factors" for further review. The case was initiated by PAX Labs (the complainant), alleging that STIIIZY and ALD (the respondents) infringed on multiple patents.

 

Previously, in a final initial determination (FID) issued by an administrative judge on March 6, 2025, it was determined that the accused products infringed on some of PAX Labs' patent rights, and the patents in question were found to be valid. However, the judge also ruled that PAX Labs did not meet the economic element of "domestic industry" as required by Section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930, therefore no violation was found.

 

The core of ITC's reconsideration this time is whether PAX Labs has made sufficient economic investments in the United States to constitute a "domestic industry." The committee pointed out in its notice that the administrative law judge incorrectly applied the "clear demarcation rule" that investments made before patent authorization do not constitute recognizable investments under elements A and B of domestic industry. ITC believes this viewpoint is erroneous, thus overturning the ruling and remanding it for further review.

 

In addition to reevaluating the domestic industry economic factors, the ITC will also review the determination in the FID regarding whether certain accused products infringe the '580 patent, as well as whether certain redesigned products infringe the '580 patent. These reviews will be decided after further scrutiny of the domestic industry issues.

 

In January 2024, e-cigarette manufacturer Pax Labs filed a lawsuit against Stiiizy and its producer ALD (ALD) for allegedly infringing on its four patents. Pax Labs claims that Stiiizy and ALD, based in Hong Kong, China, have been manufacturing and selling vaporizing devices, including batteries and pods, in a manner similar to Pax Labs' patents.

 

Pax Labs has obtained U.S. patents 11,369,756, 11,369,757, 11,766,527, and 11,759,580, which relate to methods for anti-leak pods and related devices. Pax Labs claims that these two companies have infringed on the mentioned patents.

 

According to public records, Pax Labs was founded in 2007 and specializes in the Pax series vaporizers. The company developed the Juul e-cigarette, with Juul Labs being spun off as an independent company in 2017.

 

Notice

1. This article is provided exclusively for professional research purposes related to industry, technology and policy. Any reference to brands or products is made solely for the purpose of objective description and does not constitute an endorsement, recommendation, or promotion of any brand or product.

2. The use of nicotine products, including but not limited to cigarettes, e-cigarettes, and heated tobacco products, is associated with significant health risks. Users are required to comply with all relevant laws and regulations in their respective jurisdictions.

3. This article is strictly restricted from being accessed or viewed by individuals under the legal age.

Copyright

This article is either an original work by 2Firsts or a reproduction from third-party sources with the original source clearly indicated. The copyright and usage rights of this article belong to 2Firsts or the original source. Unauthorized reproduction, distribution, or any other unauthorized use of this article by any entity or individual is strictly prohibited. Violators will be held legally responsible. For copyright-related matters, please contact: info@2firsts.com

AI Assistance Disclaimer

This article may have utilized AI to enhance translation and editing efficiency. However, due to technical limitations, errors may occur. Readers are advised to refer to the sources provided for more accurate information.

This article should not be used as a basis for any investment decisions or advice, and 2Firsts assumes no direct or indirect liability for any errors in the content.

Brazil Police Seize 5,000 Illegal Vapes Linked to IGNITE Brand
Brazil Police Seize 5,000 Illegal Vapes Linked to IGNITE Brand
Brazil’s Federal Highway Police seized approximately 5,000 illegal vaping devices branded as “IGNITE” in Mandaguaçu, Paraná state. The confiscated products will undergo inventory and investigation by the Federal Revenue Service.
Apr.24 by 2FIRSTS.ai
The Rise of a Global Black Market in Nicotine Pouches
The Rise of a Global Black Market in Nicotine Pouches
As global demand for oral nicotine products surges, a shadow supply chain is quietly taking hold—powered by counterfeit manufacturing, brand exploitation, and regulatory blind spots. A 2Firsts investigation has uncovered how unauthorized ZYN and VELO pouches, priced as low as $1 per can, are sold in bulk on Chinese B2B platforms and exported to Western markets with little oversight.
May.06
Baltimore, U.S., Targets Philip Morris Over ZYN Marketing to Youth
Baltimore, U.S., Targets Philip Morris Over ZYN Marketing to Youth
Baltimore city officials have filed a lawsuit against Philip Morris International, Swedish Match North America, and Swedish Match USA, accusing the companies of targeting minors in marketing their ZYN nicotine pouches. PMI said it had not yet received the complaint and stressed that its products are marketed exclusively to adults aged 21 and over.
May.12 by 2FIRSTS.ai
2Firsts Successfully Hosts NGP+AI Workshop, Launches Global Call for Outstanding AI Application Cases
2Firsts Successfully Hosts NGP+AI Workshop, Launches Global Call for Outstanding AI Application Cases
On April 15, 2025, 2Firsts held its first “NGP+AI” workshop in Shenzhen, focusing on real-world AI applications in the NGP industry—from formula digitization to automated flavor development and compliance tools. The event gathered professionals across R&D and tech roles. 2Firsts also launched a global call for outstanding NGP+AI use cases, offering media exposure, resource access, and innovation support to accelerate the industry’s intelligent transformation.
May.08
Word Vape Show Insights| Divergent Brand-Overseas Routes: UK Brands Target the Middle East, Southeast Asian Brands Land in Africa, and US Hits Struggling for Exports?
Word Vape Show Insights| Divergent Brand-Overseas Routes: UK Brands Target the Middle East, Southeast Asian Brands Land in Africa, and US Hits Struggling for Exports?
At the 2025 Dubai World Vape Show, 2Firsts observed a clear trend: global vape brands are speeding up their overseas expansion, but their routes are parting.
Jun.20 by 2FIRSTS.ai
Japan Tobacco Q1 2025 Results: Revenue Up 11.7% to $5.8 Billion, Heated Tobacco Sales Rise 28%
Japan Tobacco Q1 2025 Results: Revenue Up 11.7% to $5.8 Billion, Heated Tobacco Sales Rise 28%
Japan Tobacco Inc. (JT) reported first-quarter revenue of ¥827 billion ($5.8 billion), up 11.7% year-on-year, driven by double-digit growth in reduced-risk products (RRP). The company announced plans to divest its pharmaceutical business, with the transaction expected to close in the second half of the year. Management reiterated its medium- to long-term strategic goal of achieving approximately 15% market share in key heated tobacco markets by the end of 2028.
May.07 by 2FIRSTS.ai